Published ahead of print on March 23, 2006, doi:10.1164/rccm.200601-125OC
© 2006 American Thoracic Society doi: 10.1164/rccm.200601-125OC
Abnormal Pulmonary Function in Adults with Sickle Cell AnemiaPulmonary Center, Department of Medicine, Boston Comprehensive Sickle Cell Center, Boston University School of Medicine and School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Elizabeth S. Klings, M.D., Pulmonary Center, R-304, Boston University School of Medicine, 715 Albany Street, Boston, MA 02118. E-mail: eklings{at}lung.bumc.bu.edu
Rationale: Pulmonary complications of sickle cell anemia (Hb-SS) commonly cause morbidity, yet few large studies of pulmonary function tests (PFTs) in this population have been reported. Objectives: PFTs (spirometry, lung volumes, and diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide [DLCO]) from 310 adults with Hb-SS were analyzed to determine the pattern of pulmonary dysfunction and their association with other systemic complications of sickle cell disease. Methods: Raw PFT data were compared with predicted values. Each subject was subclassified into one of five groups: obstructive physiology, restrictive physiology, mixed obstructive/restrictive physiology, isolated low DLCO, or normal. The association between laboratory data of patients with decreased DLCO or restrictive physiology and those of normal subjects was assessed by multivariate linear regression. Measurements and Main Results: Normal PFTs were present in only 31 of 310 (10%) patients. Overall, adults with Hb-SS were characterized by decreased total lung capacities (70.2 ± 14.7% predicted) and DLCO (64.5 ± 19.9%). The most common PFT patterns were restrictive physiology (74%) and isolated low DLCO (13%). Decreased DLCO was associated with thrombocytosis (p = 0.05), with hepatic dysfunction (elevated alanine aminotransferase; p = 0.07), and a trend toward renal dysfunction (elevated blood urea nitrogen and creatinine; p = 0.05 and 0.07, respectively). Conclusions: Pulmonary function is abnormal in 90% of adult patients with Hb-SS. Common abnormalities include restrictive physiology and decreased DLCO. Decreased DLCO may indicate more severe sickle vasculopathy characterized by impaired hepatic and renal function.
Key Words: airway obstruction dyspnea restrictive disease
Sickle cell anemia (Hb-SS) results from homozygosity for a point mutation in the Dyspnea is a frequent complaint amongst patients with sickle cell disease, the etiology of which is unclear and likely multifactorial (4, 5). Studies of lung function to date in this population have been of modest size, often involving fewer than 50 patients (4, 611) and largely inconclusive. Their results have yielded a spectrum of abnormalities, including restrictive lung disease, abnormal diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide (DLCO), obstructive disease, and hypoxemia (4, 6, 7, 9, 12). No definitive profile for pulmonary function in sickle cell disease has emerged. As a result, clinicians find pulmonary function tests (PFTs) difficult to interpret in this population and their clinical utility for directing further investigation and therapy has not been well evaluated. Of growing concern is the link between obstructive lung disease and ACS, particularly in children (7, 13, 14). The few published studies suggest that obstructive lung disease, in some cases, plays a role in the pathogenesis of ACS (7, 13, 15). Moreover, obstructive lung disease could be a long-term sequela of recurrent episodes of ACS (6, 9). Larger scale studies are necessary to elucidate more clearly the interaction between lung function and ACS. In addition, certain findings on PFTs might be a marker of other complications of sickle vasculopathy. For example, isolated decreased DLCO is a well-established finding associated with PH (16, 17). However, its role as a marker or predictor of PH in the Hb-SS population is unknown. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the relation of the demographic, clinical, and laboratory characteristics to lung function in the sickle cell disease (SCD) population. PFTs were done on subjects recruited as part of the Cooperative Study of Sickle Cell Disease (CSSCD), a cross-sectional epidemiologic study. Some of the results of these studies have been previously presented in the form of an abstract at the American Society of Hematology 47th Annual Meeting (18).
Patient Database PFTs were collected as part of the CSSCD, which enrolled and monitored more than 4,000 patients with SCD evaluated at 1 of 23 participating clinical centers across the United States between 1978 and 1998 (19, 20). One of the primary goals of the CSSCD was to collect data on the clinical course of SCD from birth to death. From the original study population, only the 2,061 (51%) subjects with sickle cell anemia were included in this study. The study population was further limited by inclusion of only those subjects who were African American and over the age of 18 yr. A history of ACS was assessed as part of the original data collection. ACS was defined as (1) a new infiltrate on chest radiograph or (2) pleuritic chest pain and/or dyspnea in addition to an abnormal ventilationperfusion scan. As part of the standard protocol established by the CSSCD, each subject underwent pulmonary function testing three times to ensure reproducibility. If the results from the three studies differed by more than 2%, the study was considered to be of poor quality. Before entering into the database, all PFTs were reviewed for quality by pulmonologists at either Harlem Hospital (New York, NY) or Howard University Medical Center (Washington, DC) as part of the standard protocol. On our review of the data, we considered data insufficient if the evaluation was considered poor quality or if more than 25% of the data for a subject were missing, suggesting an inability to perform the tests correctly; these cases were subsequently removed from our database. Review of these data was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Boston University/Boston Medical Center (Boston, MA).
Pulmonary Function Testing
Classification of Pulmonary Function
Statistical Analysis
Patient Characteristics A total of 310 adult subjects were eligible for this study after subjects who were not African American, not homozygous for Hb S, and without complete PFTs were excluded. The average age of the subjects was 30.7 ± 10.3 yr (range, 2067 yr) and 41% were males (Table 1). Subjects had a normal body habitus as reflected by a body mass index of 21.3 ± 4.2 kg/m2. ACS was common in this population, with 37% of subjects reporting a history of ACS before enrollment in the study and an additional 38% reported an incident episode during the follow-up period.
Laboratory Values The hematologic profile of the subjects was reflective of adults with Hb-SS (Table 1). Anemia (Hb, 8.25 ± 1.44 g/dl), leukocytosis (white blood cell count [WBC], 11.75 ± 2.64 cells/L/mm3), and thrombocytosis [platelet count, 410.96 (± 113.46) x 105/ml] were present. There was evidence of ongoing hemolysis characterized by an elevation in lactate dehydrogenase (497.39 ± 166.67 U/L; normal, 100250 U/L), aspartate aminotransferase (47.24 ± 23.93 U/L; normal, 540 U/L), and bilirubin (3.62 ± 2.13 mg/dl; normal, 0.31.2 mg/dl) concentrations (26). There was a mild elevation of the hepatic enzyme alanine aminotransferase (ALT, 44.90 ± 52.31 U/L). Renal function as assessed by serum creatinine concentration was within normal laboratory ranges in this population; however, creatinine is now known to be an insensitive measure of glomerular filtration rate in Hb-SS (27).
Pulmonary Function in Patients with Hb-SS
Effect of ACS on Lung Function Two hundred and twenty-one of the 310 subjects (71.3%) had at least one episode of ACS before obtaining pulmonary function studies (Table 3). Overall, this group was characterized by a trend toward lower TLC (69.17 vs. 72.83%; p = 0.06) and adjusted DLCO (63.32 vs. 67.81%; p = 0.10) compared with those without a history of ACS. The patterns of pulmonary function abnormalities observed in those with a history of ACS were similar to those without a history of ACS with restrictive disease and an abnormal diffusion capacity predominating.
Decreased DLCO Is Associated with Increasing Age As our population did not have a predominance of obstructive disease as observed in other studies of the pediatric population (7, 1315), we evaluated the effects of age on TLC and DLCO (Figure 1). Interestingly, a negative linear correlation existed between DLCO and age, suggesting that in adults with Hb-SS, disruption of alveolarcapillary gas exchange may be a potential mechanism for hypoxemia in older adults with Hb-SS. There was no association between TLC and age in this population (data not shown).
Association of Restrictive Lung Disease with Severity of Hb-SS The multivariate regression analysis adjusting for age resulted in a trend toward association between the presence of restrictive lung disease and a more severe Hb-SS phenotype (Table 4). This phenotype is characterized by more severe anemia (Hb concentration, 8.3 vs. 8.7 g/dl [p = 0.08]; hematocrit, 24.7 vs. 26.2% [p = 0.05]) and leukocytosis (WBC, 11.93 x 103 vs. 10.95 x 103 cells/mm3; p = 0.06), compared with Hb-SS patients with normal PFTs. Additional linear regression analysis revealed a negative correlation between TLC and WBC (r = 0.15, p = 0.01; data not shown).
Association of Decreased DLCO with Systemic Disease After adjustment for age, the presence of low DLCO was associated with an increase in platelet count (441,000 vs. 391,900; p = 0.05) and blood urea nitrogen (BUN) concentration (10.9 vs. 8.3 mg/dl; p = 0.05), compared with those with normal DLCO or normal PFTs (Table 4). There was a trend toward increased ALT (59.2 vs. 31.1 U/L; p = 0.08) and creatinine concentrations (1.11 vs. 0.8 mg/dl; p = 0.07) in the patients with decreased DLCO compared with those with normal DLCO. In addition, linear regression revealed a negative correlation between DLCO and both BUN (r = 0.22, p = 0.0002) and creatinine (r = 0.22, p = 0.0003) concentrations, suggesting that worsening diffusion capacity may be a marker for systemic vasculopathy. Interestingly, there was no correlation between DLCO and the severity of anemia. Uncorrected DLCO had a positive linear association with Hb concentration (Figure 2), as would be expected in a non-SCD population, suggesting that correcting the DLCO for the level of anemia in our study did not falsely modify the results.
Pulmonary complications of adult Hb-SS are responsible for 2030% of the mortality observed in this population (2, 3, 8). Although PH occurs in about one-third of patients with Hb-SS (28), it is not the only etiology of dyspnea observed in this population. We and others have found that at least one-half of adults with sickle cell disease are at least mildly dyspneic and that dyspnea, in some cases, is not associated with echocardiographic evidence of PH ([4]; and E. S. Klings, unpublished observations). Prior studies have suggested that abnormal pulmonary function tests are the first objective sign of chronic sickle cell lung disease and that they could be helpful in patient management (8). Previously, multiple small studies have demonstrated a spectrum of PFT abnormalities in adult sickle cell disease including restrictive physiology, decreased DLCO, hypoxemia, and obstructive disease (4, 5, 8, 10, 12, 26). Our analysis is the first large-scale multicenter effort to report PFTs in adults with Hb-SS. Pulmonary function was abnormal in 90% of our cases and PFTs may allow clinicians to objectively assess dyspnea in this population. The most common PFT abnormality observed was restrictive disease. According to the American Thoracic Society guidelines, the best diagnostic test for the presence of restrictive disease is a TLC less than 80% predicted (25). When we examined the group of patients with restrictive disease, an interesting pattern emerged. Of the 230 subjects with restrictive disease, only 111 (48.3%) had the full constellation of low TLC, abnormal spirometry (reduced FEV1 and FVC, with an FEV1/FVC of at least 70%) and reduced DLCO. The remaining subjects were characterized by low lung volumes with normal spirometry. The categorization of these subjects together reflects the fact that low TLC alone is enough to make a diagnosis of restriction (25). Our population demonstrates a divergence of spirometry and lung volumes, contradicting other studies in the literature. Previously, in a large-scale study of a healthy white population, only 2.4% of subjects with a normal FVC had restrictive disease and it was recommended that spirometry alone was sufficient to exclude the presence of restriction unless a high degree of clinical suspicion was present (29). In Hb-SS, it appears clear that spirometry alone is not sufficient to predict the presence of restrictive lung disease. One explanation for this may be racial differences inherent to the sickle cell population. Race is an important determinant of lung function. Previous studies have demonstrated that, on average, equations for predicted values of PFT data based on data generated in white subjects overestimate the TLC, FEV1, and FVC by 12% and the RV and FRC by 7% (25). Although all our data were corrected for race before analysis, there may still be a differential pattern present. Another possible explanation may stem from extrapulmonary causes of restrictive physiology. In the Hb-SS population, one extrapulmonary mechanism of restriction would be ineffective inspiration due to chest wall pain related to peripheral vasoocclusion, prior rib infarctions, or vertebral disease (30). Although the PFTs obtained in this study were done while the subjects were clinically at their baseline, even when clinically well, patients with Hb-SS may have subacute vasoocclusion (31). The amount of chest wall discomfort experienced by the subjects at the time of their testing is unknown but could have contributed to the low lung volumes observed. In addition, there may be differences in chest wall and vertebral structure among adults with Hb-SS contributing to the restrictive physiology. This could be due to repeated bony infarctions during growth and development and the spinal osteoporosis and osteomalacia typical of Hb-SS (3234). NonSCD-specific etiologies of extrapulmonary restriction such as obesity may be playing a role in the restrictive physiology observed in a subset of the subjects observed. The presence of restrictive physiology was associated with a trend toward more severe clinical disease, as exemplified by lower total hemoglobin concentrations and hematocrits, leukocytosis, and renal dysfunction (elevated BUN and creatinine; Table 4). The association of leukocytosis with a decrease in the TLC supports the notion that restrictive lung disease occurs as a result of repeated episodes of ACS and may be a risk factor for mortality (2). The occurrence of more frequent episodes of ACS may be a risk factor for the development of pulmonary fibrosis, a common etiology of restrictive physiology on PFTs. In addition, this suggests that the patients with restrictive lung disease have a greater propensity toward vasoocclusion, placing them at increased risk for the development of bony infarcts. Interestingly, we noted an association between chronic organ dysfunction of the lungs and the kidneys in our population, confirming findings of prior studies and suggesting an etiologic link between these two entities (35). An equally interesting finding is the presence of decreased DLCO in adults with Hb-SS. In 13% of subjects, this was the only PFT abnormality observed. Isolated decreased DLCO can be a marker for early interstitial lung disease (36) or, more commonly, is associated with the presence of PH. In patients with systemic sclerosis, DLCO not exceeding 55% predicted may be observed in patients up to 5 yr before the diagnosis of PH and is thought to be an early screening tool in this population (17, 37). Moreover, in patients with idiopathic pulmonary arterial hypertension, low DLCO is not only a marker of PH but is also an independent predictor of mortality (16). Unfortunately, as the CSSCD was designed before the determination of the importance of PH in the natural history of SCD, echocardiographic data are not available for the majority of the study subjects. Because of this, a definitive conclusion about the relationship between reduced DLCO and the presence of PH cannot be made. We recognize that this is a shortcoming of the current study and recommend a longitudinal study evaluating pulmonary function tests and echocardiograms in adults with Hb-SS to clarify this issue. Age-adjusted multivariate analysis revealed a link between the presence of low DLCO and markers of hepatic and renal dysfunction and with thrombocytosis. Prior studies of PH in Hb-SS have revealed an association of PH with a history of renal dysfunction and an elevation in ALT (28, 38). In addition, platelets appear to have an important role pathogenically in the development of PH, both as mediators of serotonin metabolism and in their role in thrombosis. These observations support the notion that decreased DLCO may be associated with PH in the SCD population. Unfortunately, the lack of correlative echocardiographic data limits our ability to draw definitive conclusions about the link between decreased DLCO and PH in this population. Limitations of the current analysis stem from the study design. As this was a cross-sectional study of pulmonary function data, it is impossible to assess the longitudinal effects of Hb-SS disease on pulmonary function. The lack of a non-SCD control group also limits the interpretability of this study somewhat. It would be interesting to determine whether the apparent obstructive disease observed in the pediatric Hb-SS population undergoes a transition to a more restrictive pattern in adulthood. In addition, testing for airway hyperreactivity, such as response to inhaled bronchodilators or methacholine challenge testing, was not done. Its possible that subjects with coexistent asthma may not have been detected in the current study as airflow typically normalizes in these patients between acute exacerbations. A large-scale prospective study of patients with Hb-SS would be helpful in determining the association of asthma with Hb-SS, the role of asthma in the development of sickle cell lung disease, and the usefulness of the presence of decreased DLCO as a marker for PH. In addition, further work needs to be performed to more clearly delineate the etiologies of restrictive disease in Hb-SS, the potential role that parenchymal lung disease plays in the pathogenesis of hypoxemia in this population, and the extent and severity of PFT abnormalities in Hb-SC disease (compound heterozygosity for Hb S and Hb C [HBB, Glu6Lys]), another common genotype of sickle cell disease. In conclusion, pulmonary function is abnormal in 90% of adults with Hb-SS. It is likely that abnormal pulmonary function reflects intrinsic lung disease in these patients and that the mechanisms of dyspnea are more complex in this population than originally appreciated. Greater understanding of the diagnostic utility of pulmonary function testing in this population is paramount as it could lead to a more comprehensive appraisal of the mechanisms responsible for dyspnea and hypoxemia.
The authors thank the investigators of the Cooperative Study of Sickle Cell Disease, who over many years, obtained PFTs and blood samples from all patients.
This work was supported by NHLBI grants K 23 HL079003-01 (E.S.K.), HL RO1 68,970 (M.H.S.), and T32 HL007501 (V.G.N.). Originally Published in Press as DOI: 10.1164/rccm.200601-125OC on March 23, 2006 Conflict of Interest Statement: None of the authors has a financial relationship with a commercial entity that has an interest in the subject of this manuscript. Received in original form January 27, 2006; accepted in final form March 22, 2006
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||