Published ahead of print on August 11, 2004, doi:10.1164/rccm.200404-458OC
© 2004 American Thoracic Society doi: 10.1164/rccm.200404-458OC
Influence of Weight and Sleep Apnea Status on Immunologic and Structural Features of the UvulaUnité de Recherche en Pneumologie, Centre de Recherche de l'Hôpital Laval, Institut Universitaire de Cardiologie et de Pneumologie de l'Université Laval, Québec, Quebec, Canada Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Frédéric Sériès, M.D., Hôpital Laval, 2725 Chemin Sainte-Foy, Québec, PQ, G1V 4G5 Canada. E-mail: Frederic.Series{at}med.ulaval.ca
We investigated the influence of weight and obstructive sleep apnea status on inflammatory and histologic features of the uvula. Tissue samples resected during uvulopalatopharyngoplasty in 11 snorers without obstructive sleep apnea, 11 subjects with obstructive sleep apnea and of similar body mass index and age, and 8 additional obese subjects with obstructive sleep apnea were examined by immunohistochemistry and histologic staining techniques. The frequency and distribution of immune cells, the amount of collagen, and the integrity of the elastin fiber network were evaluated in proximal and distal uvular sections. T cell (CD4+, CD8+) and macrophage counts were higher in the more obese apneic subjects than in the other two groups. In all patients, T cell counts correlated with body mass index, but there was no relationship with the apneahypopnea index. A positive correlation was found between elastin fiber network disorganization score and apneahypopnea index. We conclude that (1) the amount of inflammatory markers is linked to obesity rather than to sleep-related breathing disorders, and (2) obstructive sleep apnea is associated with a structural alteration of the extracellular matrix of upper airway tissue.
Key Words: collagen elastin inflammation obesity upper airways Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is characterized by recurrent episodes of upper airway (UA) obstruction during sleep. It is usually associated with repetitive hypoxemia, fragmentation of sleep, and cardiovascular complications (15). Epidemiologic studies have estimated the prevalence of OSA in the adult population at between 2 and 4% (6, 7), with age (8, 9), sex (10), and weight (11) being three major factors influencing the prevalence. The maintenance of UA patency depends on the balance between collapsing and dilating forces. Many forces contribute to UA collapse, including the negative transmural pressure gradient and tissue weight. They are counterbalanced by the traction and stiffening of UA tissues resulting from the contraction of dilator muscles. However, in patients with OSA, UA occlusion occurs despite of an increase in UA dilator neuromuscular activity (1214). Not only is the electromyographic activity of UA dilator muscles higher but their capacity to generate tension is also higher as shown in vitro with the musculus uvulae (15). The discrepancy between the increase in neuromuscular activity and the force developed by the UA dilator muscles, and the persisting propensity of the UA to collapse, may be explained by functional abnormalities of UA tissues that would alter the transmission of the stabilizing force resulting from the contraction of UA muscles to the whole UA structure. We have previously shown that uvular stiffness is higher in subjects with OSA compared with nonapneic snorers (16). This increase in uvular elastance was found to positively correlate with the apnea index, suggesting that the mechanical properties of UA tissues contribute to the ability of UA dilator muscles to stabilize the UA. Recurrent episodes of UA fluttering and/or UA closure can lead to the development of an inflammatory process and of histologic alterations of UA tissues that can in turn alter the integrity of the extracellular matrix and interfere with the mechanical properties of soft tissues. Only a few studies have examined the inflammatory features of UA tissues in OSA (17), particularly in the uvular mucosa (18, 19). The lack of adequate control subjects (if any) and the descriptive nature of the published results make it difficult to draw any firm conclusions about the role of local inflammatory processes and histologic alterations in the development of uvular functional abnormalities. The primary aim of the present study was to examine the influence of sleep-related obstructive breathing disorders and its severity on uvular tissue histologic characteristics. The proximal and distal sections of the uvula were investigated separately because the degree of tissular abnormality may vary with the degree of mechanical stress. Some of the results of this study have been previously reported in the form of an abstract (20).
Subjects Thirty subjects (Table 1) who underwent an uvulopalatopharyngoplasty (UPPP) for the treatment of OSA or nonapneic snoring were included in the study. None of the subjects had been previously treated for OSA or snoring at the time of surgery. No subject was taking neuroleptics, antidepressors, or any medication that affects breathing during sleep. No subjects with diabetes mellitus were included. All had normal thyroid function. All subjects had a conventional sleep recording taken preceding UPPP. The 30 subjects were distributed into 3 groups (Table 1). The first group was made up of nonapneic snorers, the second consisted of patients with OSA whose body mass index (BMI) was similar to that of the snorers (OSA 1), and the third group was made up of subjects with OSA who could not be associated with nonapneic snorers on the basis of their BMI (OSA 2). There was a similar number of smokers in each group (four among the nonapneic snorers, three in the OSA 1 group, and three in the OSA 2 group). The other subjects were nonsmokers or had stopped smoking for more than 1 year. No alcohol intake was reported by three nonapneic snorers, four OSA 1 subjects, and three OSA 2 subjects. Alcohol consumption was considered low to moderate (two or fewer glasses of alcoholic beverage per day) among the other subjects. No subject was known to have asthma or allergic rhinitis and none was using topical steroids. The internal review board of our institution (Université Laval, Québec, PQ, Canada) approved the protocol and informed consent was obtained from each subject.
Sleep Studies The sleep studies were conducted using conventional polysomnographic techniques (21, 22). Airflow was quantified with the nasal pressure signal obtained from nasal prongs (nasal oxygen cannula [Baxter, Valencia, CA] or a nasal CO2 sample line [Ohmeda, Madison, WI]) connected to a pressure transducer (Validyne MP-45 [Validyne Engineering, Northridge, CA], ± 100 cm H2O) (23). Apnea was defined as an interruption of airflow for more than 10 seconds. Hypopnea was defined as a 50% reduction in airflow for more than 10 seconds associated with a drop of at least 3% in blood oxygen saturation and/or arousal or awakening.
Biopsy Procedures
Immunohistochemistry
Quantification of Immunohistochemical Staining
Histologic Staining
Morphologic Analysis
Statistical Analysis Data are expressed as means ± SD. Anthropometric data were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance. Comparisons between groups were performed by the Tukey multiple comparison technique. The normality assumption was verified using graphic representations and the ShapiroWilk test. The Brown and Forsythe variation of Levene's statistic test was used to verify the homogeneity of variances. All assumptions were fulfilled except for BMI and the apneahypopnea index (AHI). Logarithm transformations were applied to these variables to fulfill the normality and variance assumptions. One-way analysis of variance was used to analyze disorganization data. An arc sinus transformation of the square root was applied as these values are expressed as percentages. Categorical variables were analyzed by Fisher exact test. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to measure the relationship between parameters. Results were considered significant at p 0.05. All analyses were conducted with the SAS statistical package (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).
Anthropometric and polysomnographic data are summarized in Table 1. On the basis of selection criteria, OSA 2 patients had a significantly higher BMI than did subjects of the two other groups. The OSA 1 and OSA 2 groups also differed in neck circumference, which was significantly higher in the OSA 2 group. The neck circumference of both OSA groups was also significantly higher than for snorers. No difference was found in AHI, desaturation index, or magnitude of SaO2 fall at night between the two OSA groups.
Immunohistochemistry
An independent positive relationship was found for the entire study population between CD4+ and CD8+ cell counts and BMI (Figure 2). A similar relationship was observed between CD4+ and CD8+ cell counts and neck circumference (r = 0.5, p 0.0002). Interestingly, no relationship was found between these cell counts and AHI, desaturation index, or percent total sleep time < 90% SaO2.
Morphology The structural arrangement of the network of elastin fibers was homogeneous in the proximal uvular tissue, with no difference between the three groups (data not shown). However, the structural arrangement was nonhomogeneous in the different fields of the distal part of the uvula. Figure 1 shows an example of elastin fiber staining in distal uvular sections. In the three subject groups the percentage of disorganization was more important in the mucosal than in the perimuscular tissue (p = 0.006) (Table 3). While the percentage of elastin fibers disorganization was slightly higher in the mucosal tissue of the OSA 1 and OSA 2 groups than in nonapneic snorers, the difference was not significant. The percentage of elastin fiber disorganization in the mucosal tissue positively correlated with the AHI (r = 0.61, p = 0.002) and the desaturation index (r = 0.59, p = 0.003) for all subjects.
We found that OSA associated with obesity was a more important determinant of uvular tissue inflammatory features than the sleep apnea status itself. OSA also altered the organization of elastin fibers in the distal part of the uvula. Previous studies have focused on the effects of snoring/sleep apnea status on the inflammatory process in the UA mucosa. Proinflammatory mediators and a higher proportion of polymorphonuclear cells have been observed in the uvular tissue of snorers and apneic subjects than in control subjects (17). Other studies have reported histopathologic changes in the soft palate of patients with OSA (15, 29, 30). For instance, Sekosan and coworkers reported that the total leukocyte count was higher in the mucosa of the uvular tissue of patients with OSA than in a control group of postmortem subjects who were supposed to have been free of nocturnal breathing disorders (18). Paulsen and coworkers (19) found that the number of leukocytes (mainly CD3+ lymphocytes) along the uvular epithelialconnective boundary is higher in the patient group than in the control group. In both these studies, the use of postmortem samples as control tissues may have significantly interfered with interpretation of the data because OSA was ruled out only by medical histories, which are known to be unspecific, and because postmortem cell damage can interfere with immune cell counts (31). Furthermore, and most importantly, the anthropomorphic characteristics (BMI and neck circumference) of the subjects in these studies significantly differed between OSA and control subjects. This would presumably affect the inflammatory features of the tissue, as our results would suggest.
It is now acknowledged that obesity is a proinflammatory condition. This is attributed to the endocrine properties of adipose tissue (32), with the release of inflammatory mediators such as interleukin-6 and tumor necrosis factor- One could ask to what extent UA inflammation could be involved in the pathophysiology of UA closure. McNicholas and coworkers (38) reported that patients with acute exacerbations of allergic rhinitis (which is known to be associated with UA inflammation) have longer and more frequent episodes of disordered breathing during sleep than during the remission phase. In acute UA inflammation, several factors such as edema, modifications in surface tension forces, and/or tissue stiffening may impede the transmission of the traction forces developed by UA dilator muscle contraction. In the present study, no correlation was found between the presence of immune cells in the uvular mucosa and the AHI. In the absence of a clinical allergic context, tissue inflammation would be a consequence rather than a cause of breathing disturbances. Because the frequency of nocturnal breathing disorders was the same in the two OSA groups, there was no evidence that uvular tissue inflammatory infiltrates contributed to OSA severity. No measurements were obtained from a nonsnoring group. Results from such a group would be helpful to specifically evaluate the effect of snoring per se on UA tissue inflammatory features. However, just as we were convinced that a polysomnographic study had to be done in all our subjects, the plus value of including a nonsnoring group would depend on our ability to firmly exclude any possible diagnosis of sleep-disordered breathing in these patients. Given the limited diagnostic value of clinical prediction rules, the only alternative would be to conduct presurgery polysomnographic studies. This would exclude the possibility of using postmortem specimens (in addition to the inaccuracy of measurements when using cadaver tissue samples). On the other hand, other UA tissues such as tonsillar tissue can be obtained from patients undergoing tonsillectomies. However, this procedure is rarely performed in adults like those who participated to the present study. In addition, significant differences in age and BMI could be anticipated between study subjects, which would dramatically interfere with the interpretation of the results, particularly in the context of the results obtained in the present study. Therefore, when it is totally unacceptable to collect UA samples (other than limited tongue biopsies) in a well-selected and well-identified population free of any surgical indication, it is difficult to see how we could have included nonsnoring subjects in our study. Because of this, the data of Sekosan and coworkers (18) are particularly important for supporting the hypothesis that snoring by itself leads to upper airway inflammation independent of apneic activity. It is reasonable to question to what extent the lack of significant differences between snorers and OSA 1 subjects may be due to an overlap between these two groups in terms of sleep-disordered breathing. From a clinical point of view, none of the snoring subjects reported any symptoms suggestive of sleep apnea, their weight had remained stable for the previous 6 months, they were not taking any medication, and none of them complained of allergic rhinitis. Furthermore, for these subjects, at least 40% of the recorded total sleep time was spent supine. The usual conditions that might potentially be associated with night-to-night worsening of sleep apnea activity were thus not seen in these patients. Another way to evaluate the possible influence of fluctuations of nocturnal breathing disorders is to examine the homogeneity of the inflammatory tissue features in our different groups. We reasoned that if a significant overlap in nocturnal breathing disorders between our snoring subjects and subjects with sleep apnea altered our capacity to identify differences in inflammatory features, we would expect a greater fluctuation in the inflammatory variables in our nonapneic snorers. Data reported in Table 2 clearly demonstrate that the fluctuation in these variables was dramatically lower in the nonapneic group than in the two other groups. Insofar as these UA tissue inflammatory markers can be considered as reflecting the long-term consequences of nocturnal breathing disorders, there is no evidence that fluctuations in AHI could account for the nonsignificant differences in these markers between nonapneic and mildly apneic subjects.
A third methodologic issue that could alter the significance of our findings is the lack of statistical power. We determined that the statistical power was 39% for the study reported here and that 48 (16 per group) patients would be needed to reach a statistically significant difference in elastin fiber disorganization between OSA subjects and snorers with a 80% statistical power and an We found that elastin network disorganization correlated with AHI. Given the similarity in elastin disorganization scores for the two OSA groups and the difference in tissular inflammatory features between the two groups, it is reasonable to hypothesize that these two findings are unrelated. The proximal and distal sections of the uvula behave differently, with a significant difference in disorganization scores between the three fields in the distal section of the uvula. Such local alterations in elastin fiber organization may result from recurrent tissue stretching and crushing of the uvula between anterior (tongue) and posterior (posterior pharyngeal wall) UA tissues (39). Such extracellular matrix disorganization has been previously reported in the bronchial mucosa of subjects with asthma (28). It can be speculated that the disorganization of the elastin fiber network may contribute to the loss of uvular elasticity observed in vitro in patients with OSA (16). Our results show that the increase in UA tissue inflammatory features is linked to obesity rather than to obstructive sleep apnea status. Consequently, the UA inflammatory process can be dissociated from the structural alterations of the extracellular matrix observed in sleep-related breathing disorders that are independent of body weight.
The authors thank Caroline Paquet, Doris Cantin, and Sabrina Biardel for technical assistance, and Serge Simard for statistical analysis.
Supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research. Conflict of Interest Statement: F.S. does not have a financial relationship with a commercial entity that has an interest in the subject of this manuscript; J.C. does not have a financial relationship with a commercial entity that has an interest in the subject of this manuscript; D.B. does not have a financial relationship with a commercial entity that has an interest in the subject of this manuscript. Received in original form April 5, 2004; accepted in final form August 10, 2004
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||