© 2004 American Thoracic Society
Critical Care Medicine in AJRCCM 2003Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Loyola University of Chicago Stritch School of Medicine and Hines Veterans Affairs Hospital, Hines, Illinois Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Martin J. Tobin, M.D., Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Hines Veterans Affairs Hospital, Route 111N, Hines, IL 60141. E-mail: mtobin2{at}lumc.edu
Critical Care (115) Mechanical Ventilation (42) Conventional Approaches (2) Patient-Ventilator Interaction (6) Non-Conventional Modes (2) Protective Ventilation (2) Liquid Ventilation (1) Ventilator-Induced Lung Injury (15) Ventilator-Induced Diaphragmatic Injury (2) Weaning (3) Patient Posture (1) Non-Invasive Ventilation (3) Adjunctive Therapy (5) Acute Lung Injury and Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (16) Epidemiology and Genetics (2) Animal Models (4) Cellular and Molecular Mechanisms (3) Fluid Biology (4) Treatment (2) Review Articles (1) Sepsis and Shock (19) Epidemiology and Genetics (5) Mechanisms in Patients and Volunteers (2) Endotoxemia in Animals (3) Sepsis in Animals (3) Treatment of Sepsis (3) Nonseptic Causes of Shock (3) Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia (4) Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) (5) Nosocomial Infections (3) Massive Pulmonary Hemorrhage (1) Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (2) Monitoring (4) General (2) Hemodynamic (2) Nitric Oxide (6) Ethical Issues (3) Nonpulmonary Critical Care (10) Pharmacotherapy (1) Trauma (2) Gastroenterological Disorders (1) Cardiac Disorders (1) Hematological Disorders (2) Infectious Disorders (2) Neurologic and Neuromuscular Disorders (1)
Mechanical Ventilation Conventional approaches. To determine the level of understanding of mechanical ventilation among internal medicine residents, Cox and coworkers (1) administered a 19-question examination to 259 residents at 31 residency programs. The average score on the test was 74% correct (range, 37 to 100%). Most residents correctly identified tension pneumothorax (86% correct) and clinical findings suggestive of severe hypotension secondary to auto positive end-expiratory pressure (intrinsic PEEP) (93% correct). High rates of incorrect answers were found for the setting of tidal volume in patients with the acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) (48% incorrect), identifying whether a patient was ready for a weaning trial (38% incorrect), and recognizing an indication for noninvasive ventilation (27% incorrect). Higher scores were associated with closed-unit versus open-unit organization (76 versus 71% correct), resident perception of greater versus lesser knowledge (79 versus 71% correct), and graduation from a U.S. versus a foreign medical school (75 versus 69% correct). Only 46% of residents were satisfied with their training in mechanical ventilation. The authors conclude that residents in internal medicine programs may not be gaining knowledge essential for providing care to patients requiring mechanical ventilation. An editorial commentary by Dunn (2) accompanies this article.
Patient-ventilator interaction. When mechanical ventilation is delivered under normocapnic conditions, its cessation is accompanied by central apneas. To determine whether increases in tidal volume or increases in respiratory rate are responsible for the change in respiratory rhythm, Rice and coworkers (5) increased tidal volume (to 135220% of eucapnic volume) and respiratory rate (1 or 3 breaths above eucapnic rate) in seven healthy subjects during NREM sleep. During controlled ventilation, an increase in tidal volume (by 65% or more of eucapnic volume) plus an increase in rate (of 1 breath per minute) eliminated transdiaphragmatic pressure. Cessation of controlled ventilation was accompanied by prolongation of expiratory time (by two to four times the control value); the increases in expiratory time were proportional to the increases in tidal volume during controlled ventilation but were independent of further increases in ventilator rate. During and after assist-control ventilation, increases in tidal volume (to 135 to 220% of eucapnic volume) were accompanied by decreases in transdiaphragmatic pressure in proportion to the increase in tidal volume; each ventilator inflation was actively triggered and the increase in expiratory time on cessation of mechanical ventilation was less than 20% of that seen after cessation of controlled ventilation. The authors conclude that both increases in ventilator rate and delivered volume during mechanical ventilation cause inhibition of respiratory motor output via nonchemical mechanisms (neuromechanical effects of repeated and augmented lung inflation), and that the resetting of respiratory rhythm is greater with additional increase in ventilator rate than with increase in delivered volume alone. The ventilatory response to hypoxia in the presence of hypocapnia is controversial. Corne and coworkers (6) used volume-cycled ventilation to measure the ventilatory response to hypoxia during eucapnia and hypocapnia. The response of respiratory muscle pressure to hypoxia (expressed as cm H2O per percentage change in oxygen saturation) was 0.53 at eucapnia, 0.26 at end-tidal PCO2 of 6 mm Hg below eucapnia, and 0.003 at PCO2 of 12 mm Hg below eucapnia. Similar reductions were evident for respiratory rate (expressed as breaths per minute per percentage change in oxygen saturation): 0.17 at eucapnia, 0.11 at PCO2 of 6 mm Hg below eucapnia, and 0.01 at PCO2 of 12 mm Hg below eucapnia. The responses of respiratory muscle pressure and respiratory rate at a PCO2 of 12 mm Hg below eucapnia were not significantly different from zero. The authors conclude that regardless of the strength of the hypoxic ventilatory response at eucapnia, the responses are lost when PCO2 is reduced (in a stable manner) by 6 to 12 mm Hg below eucapnia. To determine the prevalence of noise in the intensive care unit (ICU) and its effect on sleep, Gabor and coworkers (7) did polysomnography on 7 mechanically ventilated patients and 6 healthy subjects over 24 hours in the ICU. Time-synchronized environmental monitoring was also performed. The average level of noise was 51 dB in the open ICU and 43 dB in an isolated single room (noise is 70 dB in a busy office, and 40 dB in a bedroom). In the patients, increases in sound occurred 37 times per hour of sleep and were responsible for 21% of all arousals and awakenings. Patient-care activities occurred 8 times per hour and were responsible for 7% of all arousals and awakenings. Compared with an open ICU, healthy subjects slept longer when placed in a single ICU room (9.5 versus 8.2 hours); sleep architecture was not altered. The authors conclude that noise and patient-care activities account for 28% of arousals and awakenings in critically ill patients receiving mechanical ventilation. Arterial pulse pressure is known to increase during mechanical inflation and decrease during exhalation secondary to cyclic changes in left-ventricular stroke output. To determine whether the changes during inflation result from improvement in left-ventricular systolic function, Vieillard-Baron and coworkers (8) did transesophageal echocardiography, Doppler studies, and arterial pressure measurements in 31 septic patients. Lung inflation produced a 16.6% increase in left-ventricular stroke volume, which was directly related to a 13.1% increase in left-ventricular diastolic volume and a 12.2% increase in left-ventricular ejection fraction. The authors conclude that the improvement in left-ventricular function during mechanical inflation is primarily the result of increased left-ventricular filling.
Nonconventional modes. In a critical care perspective, Bollen and colleagues (10) present a meta-analysis on use of high-frequency and conventional ventilation.
Protective ventilation.
Liquid ventilation.
Ventilator-induced lung injury. In pigs with surfactant deactivation induced by Tween instillation, Halter and coworkers (16) determined whether recruited alveoli would again collapse or become unstable if PEEP was not applied after the recruitment maneuver. The number and stability of alveoli was measured by in vivo microscopy. A recruitment maneuver consisting of peak pressure of 45 cm H2O plus PEEP of 35 cm H2O for 1 minute opened a significant number of alveoli, which remained stable during the maneuver. After the recruitment maneuver, pigs ventilated with PEEP of 10 cm H2O showed improved oxygenation and alveolar stability; but pigs ventilated with PEEP of 5 cm H2O showed significant alveolar instability. The authors conclude that collapsed alveoli opened by a recruitment maneuver collapse again if ventilation is not accompanied by an adequate level of PEEP. An editorial commentary Kavanagh (17) accompanies this article. Copland and coworkers (18) used gene arrays to assess global changes in gene expression after exposing in vivo adult rat lungs to 30 minutes of ventilation at high tidal volume (25 ml per kg). Thirty minutes of high-volume ventilation did not induce discernable change in lung histology or lung mechanics; obvious injury occurred when ventilation was continued for 90 minutes. Thirty minutes of high-volume ventilation, however, did cause significant upregulation of 10 genes and suppression of 12 genes. Among the upregulated genes were transcription factors, stress proteins, and inflammatory mediators. The downregulated genes were exemplified by metabolic regulatory genes. Temporal studies revealed that Egr-1 and c-Jun were increased early and before heat shock protein 70 and interleukin-1ß. All four of the genes were upregulated primarily in the bronchiolar airway epithelium. Ninety minutes of high-volume ventilation caused an increase in intracellular interleukin-1ß protein. The authors conclude that specific patterns of gene activation and suppression precede the lung injury caused by high-volume ventilation. An editorial commentary by Jacobson and Garcia (19) accompanies this article. Hypercapnic acidosis protects against lung injury caused by a direct pulmonary insult, but it is not known if it protects against injury originating in a nonpulmonary source. To investigate this issue, Laffey and coworkers (20) used a splanchnic ischemia-reperfusion injury to produce lung injury in rats. Compared with control conditions, hypercapnia (resulting from the addition of CO2 to inspired gas) attenuated protein leakage, improved oxygenation, and preserved lung mechanics. Hypercapnia had both therapeutic and prophylactic actions. Protection was dose-dependent, although benefit at inspired CO2 concentrations above 5% was small. Protection occurred despite pulmonary artery pressure being higher than the pressure during normocapnia. Hypercapnia did not alter the injury to the bowel caused by ischemia and reperfusion. The authors conclude that hypercapnia protects against lung injury in rats caused by bowel injury resulting from ischemia and reperfusion. To determine the effect of ventilation with and without a recruitment strategy on cardiopulmonary function, Duggan and coworkers (21) studied rats receiving conventional ventilation. Mortality was lower in rats ventilated with recruitment maneuvers plus PEEP than in rats ventilated without recruitment maneuvers: 59 versus 100%. Ventilation without recruitment maneuvers also resulted in greater hypoxemia, lung stiffness, pulmonary hypertension, microvascular leak, and lactic acidosis. Rats ventilated without recruitment maneuvers exhibited right-ventricular dysfunction on echocardiography and endothelial disruption on electron microscopy. The authors conclude that atelectasis arising from lack of recruitment during mechanical ventilation is accompanied by microvascular leak and right-ventricular dysfunction, which may contribute to systemic abnormalities and increased mortality. To determine whether ventilator-induced lung injury causes a systemic microvascular leak that is dependent on nitric oxide synthase expression, Choi and coworkers (22) ventilated rats for 2 hours with tidal volumes of 7 or 20 ml per kg. The larger tidal volume induced a significant microvascular leak in both the lungs and the kidneys, and also increased the serum concentration of vascular endothelial growth factor. The larger tidal volume increased the expression of endothelial nitric oxide synthase in lung and kidney tissue, but not inducible nitric oxide synthase. An inhibitor of nitric oxide synthase, N-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester, attenuated the microvascular leak in the lungs and kidneys. The authors conclude that ventilator-induced lung injury results in a systemic microvascular leak that is mediated by endothelial nitric oxide synthase. Mechanical ventilation at high tidal volume downregulates the function of alveolar sodium, potassiumATPase, and impairs clearance of lung liquid. Adir and coworkers (23) investigated whether the overexpression of sodium, potassiumATPase in alveolar epithelium increases liquid clearance in rats. Seven days before inducing lung injury with a tidal volume of 40 ml per kg, the rats were infected with a replication-incompetent adenovirus to overexpress sodium, potassium-ATPase ß1 subunit gene. Compared with sham or animals infected with a null gene, the animals infected with the ß1 subunit gene exhibited greater lung liquid clearance, greater sodium, potassium-ATPase activity, and more abundant protein. The authors conclude that overexpression of the ß1 subunit gene for sodium, potassium-ATPase in alveolar epithelium increases activity of sodium, potassium-ATPase and lung liquid clearance in rats with ventilator-induced lung injury. An editorial commentary by Saumon (24) accompanies this article. Mechanical distortion of blood vessels is known to activate endothelial cells. To determine whether airway distension with the application of PEEP promotes leukocyte recruitment, Lim and Wagner (25) used intravital microscopy in rat tracheas. Normal mechanical ventilation produced no change in leukocyte rolling velocity and the number of adherent cells over 2 hours. Ventilation with PEEP of 8 cm H2O for 1 hour caused a decrease in leukocyte rolling velocity and an increase in adhesion. PEEP did not alter leukocyte recruitment in the mesenteric circulation. Application of PEEP distal to the site of measurement in the airway did not induce leukocyte recruitment. Pretreatment with endothelin receptor and selectin inhibitors blocks the effect of PEEP on leukocyte recruitment. The authors conclude that airway distension induced by PEEP leads to inflammatory leukocyte trafficking in the airways. An editorial commentary by Uhlig (26) accompanies this article. In a critical care perspective, Dreyfuss and colleagues (27) discuss the physiological and clinical relevance of lung-borne cytokines during ventilator-induced lung injury. Tierney (28) recalls early studies of ventilator-induced lung injury.
Ventilator-induced diaphragmatic injury. In a state of the art review article, Laghi and Tobin (30) discuss disorders of the respiratory muscles.
Weaning. Ferrer and coworkers (32) randomized 43 patients who failed trials of spontaneous breathing on three consecutive days to extubation plus noninvasive ventilation or to continued intubation plus daily spontaneous breathing trials. The trial was stopped early because the end-point was reached after studying half the planned study population. Compared with conventional weaning, patients weaned with noninvasive ventilation had a shorter duration of invasive ventilation (9.5 versus 20.1 days), shorter stay in ICU (14.1 versus 25.0 days), shorter hospital stay (27.8 versus 40.8 days), less need for tracheotomy (1.5 versus 13.6%), lower incidence of nosocomial pneumonia (5.2 versus 13.6%), lower incidence of septic shock (2.1 versus 9.4%), greater ICU survival (19.9 versus 13.6%), and greater 90-day survival (about 75% versus 40%). Conventional weaning was independently associated with decreased ICU survival (odds ratio, 6.6) and decreased 90-day survival (odds ratio, 3.5). The authors conclude that use of noninvasive ventilation in patients who fail three consecutive days of conventional weaning results in shorter duration of mechanical ventilation, fewer complication, less need for tracheotomy, and increased ICU and 90-day survival. An editorial commentary by Navalesi and coworkers (33) accompanies this article.
Patient posture.
Noninvasive ventilation. To determine whether use of noninvasive ventilation is beneficial for the treatment of acute hypoxemic respiratory failure, Ferrer and coworkers (37) did a randomized trial in 105 patients with severe hypoxemia (PO2 less than 60 mm Hg or oxygen saturation less than 90% while breathing an oxygen concentration of 50%). Compared with oxygen therapy, noninvasive ventilation decreased the need for intubation (13.3% versus 28.5%), incidence of septic shock (6.1% versus 17.3%), and ICU mortality (9.2% versus 21.4%); 90-day survival was also increased. Noninvasive ventilation achieved a greater improvement in PO2 and respiratory rate over time. On multivariate analysis, noninvasive ventilation was independently associated with decreased risk of intubation and decreased 90-day mortality. The authors conclude that use of noninvasive ventilation in patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure decreased the rate of intubation and septic shock and improved survival as compared with high-concentration oxygen-therapy.
Adjunctive therapy. In nine patients with acute lung injury, Maggiore and coworkers (40) studied the fall in end-expiratory lung volume (derecruitment) during endotracheal suctioning. Suctioning performed after disconnection from the ventilator produced a decrease in lung volume of 1,466 ml. The decrease in lung volume during suctioning after disconnection from the ventilator resulted almost equally from simple disconnection (728 ml) and application of negative pressure (737 ml). The decrease in lung volume was less when suctioning was performed via a catheter introduced through the swivel adaptor of the catheter mount (733 ml) or with use of a closed suctioning system (531 ml). The decrease in lung volume during suctioning was no longer statistically significant when pressure support produced peak inspiratory pressures of 40 cm H2O during suctioning through the swivel (168 ml) or a closed system (284 ml). Oxygenation paralleled the changes in lung volumes. The authors conclude that endotracheal suctioning decreases end-expiratory lung volume in patients with acute lung injury, and that the decreases can be minimized by avoiding disconnection from the ventilator and through the use of a closed-suction system. During bench application of modern ventilators, Miller and coworkers (41) investigated the key variables affecting aerosol delivery and also assessed the relationship between bench predictions and in vivo end points in patients. With the bench studies, inhaled mass (percentage of nebulizer charge) ranged between 5.7% and 37.4%, and breath-activated nebulization and humidity were found to be the most important determinants of aerosol delivery. In patients, levels of deposited antibiotics in sputum of patients ranged from 1.1 to 19.6 µg per ml per mg, and the level correlated with predictions from the bench model. The authors conclude that bench models of aerosol delivery during mechanical ventilation can predict the delivery of aerosols in intubated patients. An editorial commentary by Dhand (42) accompanies this article.
Acute Lung Injury and Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome To determine whether ARDS complicating bacteremic sepsis has an independent effect on mortality, Eggimann and coworkers (44) analyzed data on 4,530 admissions to an ICU. There were 196 cases of bacteremic sepsis and 31 (16%) of these patients developed ARDS. On Cox proportional hazards regression, ARDS was associated with increased mortality (unadjusted hazard ratio, 1.8). After adjusting for comorbid factors present before the onset of sepsis, ARDS was still associated with increased mortality (adjusted hazard ratio, 2.2). After adjusting for nonpulmonary organ dysfunction and microbiologic factors, ARDS was not associated with increased mortality (adjusted hazard ratio, 0.6). The authors conclude that ARDS complicating bacteremic sepsis is not independently associated with short-term mortality once the severity of illness and nonpulmonary organ dysfunction have been taken into account.
Animal models. Rocco and coworkers (46) studied the effect of low-dose glucocorticoids on the lung injury caused by intraperitoneal administration of paraquat in rats. Both 10 and 25 mg/kg of paraquat induced increases in lung resistive, viscoelastic, and static elastance pressures on the first day after exposure. Hysterestivity was increased only with a paraquat dose of 25 mg/kg. Administration of methylprednisolone at either 1 or 6 hours produced attenuation of mechanical changes after 25 mg/kg of paraquat, but had no effect on changes induced by 10 mg/kg of paraquat. Collagen and elastic fibers increased in a dose-dependent fashion. Methylprednisolone prevented the increase in collagen and avoided elastogenesis. The authors conclude that methylprednisolone prevents the abnormal respiratory mechanics associated with mild lung injury caused by paraquat and minimizes the changes in tissue impedance and the extracellular matrix associated with severe lung injury caused by paraquat.
The hydrophobic surfactant protein C binds to lipopolysaccharide (which is found in airborne particles) and one of its cellular receptors, CD14. Augusto and coworkers (47) investigated the influence of surfactant protein C on the responses of immunocompetent cells to lipopolysaccharide. When associated with vesicles of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, surfactant protein C inhibited the mitogenic effect of lipopolysaccharide to a macrophage cell line (RAW 264.7). Under similar conditions, surfactant protein C inhibited the mitogenic effect of lipopolysaccharide on mouse splenocytes, inhibited the lipopolysaccharide-induced production of tumor necrosis factor-
Many genes elicited by bacteria in the lungs are regulated by
Cellular and molecular mechanisms. In a state of the art review article, Kinnula and Crapo (50) discuss superoxide dismutase in lung disease. In a state of the art review article, de Perrot (51) discusses ischemia-reperfusion injury that results after lung transplantation.
Fluid biology.
Pulmonary edema caused by scorpion venom is attributed by increased pulmonary vascular permeability. To determine effect of scorpion venom on clearance of alveolar fluid, Comellas and coworkers (54) injected rats intraperitoneally with venom (from Tityus serrulatus). Wet-to-dry weight ratio of the lung increased and clearance of lung edema decreased by about 60%. Protein abundance of the To determine whether inhibiting the production of nitric oxide by the lung influences the clearance of alveolar fluid, Tsubochi and coworkers (55) instilled endotoxin into the trachea of adult rats. Levels of nitric oxide in the lung reached a maximum at 6 hours after instillation of endotoxin, and the production was accompanied by increases in cyclic guanosine monophosphate. Clearance of alveolar fluid decreased at 6 hours and then increased at 24 hours; these changes were related to the function of sodium channels sensitive to amiloride. Administration of gadolinium chloride and aminoguanidine decreased the levels of nitric oxide and cyclic guanosine monophosphate, and inhibited the changes in alveolar fluid clearance. Inducible nitric oxide synthase was abundantly expressed in the cytoplasm of alveolar macrophages. The authors conclude that endotoxin causes the production of nitric oxide by alveolar macrophages and leads to changes in alveolar fluid clearance.
Treatment. Richard and coworkers (57) investigated the reliability of positron emission tomographic imaging in detecting the expression of genes delivered to the lungs by viral vectors. The study was conducted in normal rats and an enhanced mutant herpes simplex virus-1 thymidine kinase was used as the reporter gene. Rats were studied 3 days after the intratracheal administration of a replication-incompetent adenovirus containing a fusion gene for the mutant kinase and green fluorescent protein. The rats were injected with an imaging substance for the viral kinase, 9-(4-[18F]-fluoro-3-hydroxymethylbutyl)guanine; images were obtained 1 hour later. Measurements derived from imaging were linearly correlated with measures of thymidine kinase activity and green fluorescent protein levels in tissue (r2 = 0.96). Imaging detected expression of thymidine kinase in 15 of 16 rats, even at low viral doses. Imaging for the viral kinase was correlated with in vitro assays for both kinase activity (r2 = 0.48) and fluorescent protein (r2 = 0.46). The authors conclude that positron emission tomographic imaging is a sensitive and quantitative method for noninvasive detection of pulmonary reporter gene expression.
Review article.
Sepsis and Shock To characterize the epidemiology of septic shock, Annane and coworkers (60) analyzed data on 100,554 admissions to 22 ICUs in Paris. The overall frequency of septic shock was 8.2 per 100 admissions. Frequency increased from 7% of admissions in 1993 to 9.7% of admissions in 2000. Both the rate of pulmonary infection and septic shock caused by multiresistant bacteria increased over time. Crude mortality was 62.1% in 1993 and 55.9% in 2000. Compared with patients admitted to the ICU without sepsis, the increased risk of death secondary to septic shock was 25.7; the matched odds ratio of death was 3.9. The authors conclude that the frequency of septic shock is increasing and is involving more multiresistant strains, and that mortality is decreasing but remains higher than in nonseptic critically ill patients. To characterize the epidemiology of sepsis in children, Watson and coworkers (61) analyzed data on 1,586,253 hospitalizations in children, 19 years of age or younger. These were 42,364 cases of severe sepsis per year nationally in children (0.56 cases per 1,000 population per year). Incidence was highest in infants (5.2 per 1,000), lower in 10- to 14-year-old children (0.2 per 1,000), and 15% higher in boys than in girls. Half the cases had an underlying disease, and 23% were low-birth-weight newborns. The most common infections were respiratory (37%) and primary bacteremia (25%). Hospital mortality was 10.3%, mean length of stay was 31 days, and cost was $40,600. Annual costs were estimated at $1.97 billion nationally. The authors conclude that there are more than 42,000 cases of sepsis with 4,400 associated deaths in the United States each year. Schaaf and coworkers (62) asked, "Are patients who are genetically predisposed to increased production of interleukin-10 (as determined by interleukin-101082 polymorphism) at increased risk of severe pneumococcal infection leading to septic shock?". Polymorphisms were studied by the polymerase chain reaction in 69 patients with pneumococcal disease (61 with community-acquired pneumonia, 5 with meningitis, and 3 with pneumonia and meningitis) and 50 control subjects. No significant genotype differences were seen between the patients and the control subjects. Of 69 patients with pneumococcal disease, 13 developed septic shock. Interleukin-10 allele Ghomozygous patients had the highest risk for septic shock (odds ratio, 6.1). Release of interleukin-10 from whole blood was 46% greater in patients who were homozygous for the interleukin-10 allele G than in nonhomozygotes. No association was found between tumor necrosis factor genotypes and sepsis severity. The authors conclude that patients who are homozygous for interleukin-101082 allele G (associated with increased production of interleukin-10) are at increased risk of developing septic shock from pneumococcal infection.
In the proximal coding region of the gene for the lipopolysaccharide binding protein, a T
Mechanisms in patients and volunteers. In a clinical commentary, Vieillard-Baron and colleagues (65) discuss the use of echocardiography in assessing hemodynamic instability in sepsis.
Endotoxemia in animals. In a rat model of acute lung injury induced by lipopolysaccharide, Agorreta and coworkers (67) investigated the effect of hypoxia on expression of nitric oxide synthase-2 (the endothelial, inducible isoform of the enzyme). Exposure to hypoxia alone had no effect on the expression of nitric oxide synthase-2 in rat lungs. Intraperitoneal injection of lipopolysaccharide increased the level of nitric oxide synthase-2 in the lungs, which was further enhanced by concomitant exposure to hypoxia. Resident lung cells showed no changes in the expression of nitric oxide synthase-2 under any conditions. In in vitro experiments, lung epithelial and endothelial cell lines showed no detectable expression of nitric oxide synthase-2 with any treatment. In a macrophage cell line, expression of nitric oxide synthase-2 in response to lipopolysaccharide was not affected by concomitant exposure to hypoxia. The authors conclude that the increase in nitric oxide synthase-2 in acute lung injury caused by lipopolysaccharide results from recruitment of leukocytes that produce the enzyme, and that concomitant hypoxia increases leukocyte recruitment and further enhances the expression of nitric oxide synthase-2. Because mitochondria are the principal organelles that consume oxygen and generate reactive oxygen species, Suliman and coworkers (68) determined whether cell activation by lipopolysaccharide would cause damage to mitochondria through activation of mitochondrial DNA. A single injection of lipopolysaccharide caused a decrease in copy number of mitochondrial DNA in the liver of rats. Lipopolysaccharide caused an oxidant-dependent 3.8-kb mitochondrial DNA deletion in the region encoding NADH dehydrogenase subunits 1 and 2 and cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (which correlated with depletion of mitochondrial glutathione). Expression of mitochondrial messenger RNA and transcription of mitochondrial RNA were suppressed; expression of messenger RNA was increased for selected nuclear-encoded mitochondrial proteins. Resolution of the damage to mitochondrial DNA was mediated by importing mitochondrial transcription factor A protein (a central regulator of the copy number of mitochondrial DNA), accompanied by binding of mitochondrial protein extract to the mitochondrial transcription factor A DNAbinding site. The authors conclude that hepatic injury induced by lipopolysaccharide is associated with a specific oxidative mitochondrial DNA deletion, which inhibits mitochondrial transcription and is restored by activation of mechanisms that lead to biogenesis.
Sepsis in animals. ß2 microglobulin knockout mice (ß2M-/-) lack CD8+ T and natural killer T cells. Sherwood and coworkers (70) determined whether such mice have increased mortality when sepsis is induced by cecal ligation and puncture. Although the ß2 microglobulin knockout mice survived for longer than did wild-type mice, all eventually died. When ß2 microglobulin knockout mice were treated with anti-asialoGM1, to deplete natural killer cells, long-term survival exceeded 70%. Compared with wild-type mice, ß2 microglobulin knockout mice treated with anti-asialoGM1 did not exhibit hypothermia or metabolic acidosis after induction of sepsis and they produced less proinflammatory cytokines. Septic ß2 microglobulin knockout mice treated with anti-asialoGM1 experienced an increase in mortality with adoptive transfer of CD8+ T and natural killer cells. CD8 knockout mice treated with anti-asialoGM1, which are deficient in CD8+ T cells and natural killer cells, had a greater than 40% survival rate after inducing sepsis. Treating wild-type mice with antibodies to CD8 and asialoGM1 increased survival. The authors conclude that increased survival of ß2-microglobulin knockout mice after cecal ligation and perforation is largely consequent to depletion of CD8+ T and natural killer cells. In a sheep model of septic shock secondary to peritonitis, Sun and coworkers (71) compared the effects of low-dose vasopressin, with or without norepinephrine, on hemodynamics, histology, and survival. Mean arterial pressure was maintained with all treatments. Blood flow in the superior mesenteric artery was lower in sheep treated with vasopressin plus norepinephrine than in sheep treated with vasopressin alone. Compared with sheep treated with Ringer's lactate (control) or norepinephrine alone, sheep treated with vasopressin alone or vasopressin plus norepinephrine experienced less of an increase in blood lactate and ileal PCO2-gap. Sheep treated with vasopressin had a higher urinary output than the other groups. Survival time was 17 hours in the control group, and was higher with norepinephrine alone (20 hours), vasopressin alone (30 hours), and vasopressin plus norepinephrine (30 hours). Tissue injury was less severe in sheep receiving vasopressin alone or vasopressin plus epinephrine. The authors conclude that low-dose vasopressin (alone or in combination with norepinephrine) improves mesenteric blood flow, limits lactic acidosis and tissue injury, and increases survival in sheep with septic shock secondary to peritonitis.
Treatment of sepsis. Conventional diet (and lipid emulsions) predominates in n-6 fatty acids (including arachidonic acid), whereas fish-based lipids yield n-3 fatty acids (rich in eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid). To determine the effect of n-3 fatty acids on fat profiles and monocyte cytokine production, Mayer and coworkers (74) entered 21 patients with sepsis into a 5-day randomized trial. Before the trial, plasma-free fatty acid concentrations were greatly increased in the septic patients, and n-6 fatty acids greatly exceeded n-3 fatty acids. The high n-6/n-3 ratio was maintained during conventional lipid infusions. Within 2 days of starting the n-3 fatty acid infusion, free n-3 fatty acids increased, the n-3/n-6 ratio was reversed, and n-3 fatty acids were rapidly incorporated into the membranes of mononuclear leukocytes. Generation of proinflammatory cytokines by mononuclear leukocytes was markedly amplified during n-6 lipid infusion and suppressed during n-3 lipid infusion. After termination of n-3 lipid infusion, the concentration of free n-3 fatty acid and cytokine synthesis by mononuclear leukocytes decreased. The authors conclude that use of n-3 fatty acid infusions may achieve a favorable effect on inflammation and immunologic function in patients with sepsis in addition to nutrition.
Nonseptic causes of shock. To determine whether critical oxygen delivery, the point at which oxygen consumption becomes limited by oxygen delivery, is higher when hypoxia is caused by stagnant flow versus anemia, Morita and coworkers (77) induced sepsis in rats by cecal legation and perforation. Rats were randomized to anemic hypoxia (induced by isovolumic hemodilution) or stagnant hypoxia (induced by stepwise inflation of a balloon in the right atrium). The level for critical oxygen delivery did not differ between anemic hypoxia and stagnant hypoxia in the septic animals. The critical hemoglobin concentration for anemic hypoxia was equivalent for septic animals and control animals, indicating that tolerance to acute anemia is not altered by sepsis. The authors conclude that critical oxygen delivery did not differ between anemic and stagnant hypoxia in either septic or control rats.
Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia The clinical pulmonary infection score has been reported to have a sensitivity and specificity of greater than 90% for diagnosis of pneumonia. In 79 episodes of suspected ventilator-associated pneumonia, Fartoukh and coworkers (80) tested the reliability of the score against culture of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid as a reference standard. A physician's estimate of the probability of pneumonia had a sensitivity of 50% and a specificity of 58%. The clinical pulmonary infection score was not statistically higher in 40 episodes of confirmed pneumonia than in 39 episodes not confirmed: mean score of 6.5 versus 5.9. The score had a sensitivity of 60% and a specificity of 59%. Addition of gram-stain results of directed or blinded protected telescoping catheter to the score increased sensitivity to 78% and specificity to 56%. Addition of gram-stain results of bronchoalveolar lavage to the score achieved a sensitivity of 85% and specificity of 49%. The authors conclude that the clinical pulmonary infection score has low diagnostic accuracy and the addition of gram-stain results from a protected telescoping catheter or bronchoalveolar lavage may improve clinical decision-making. To define the microbiology of severe aspiration pneumonia in institutionalized elderly patients, El-Solh and coworkers (81) prospectively studied 95 patients with severe aspiration pneumonia older than 65 years of age admitted to their ICU from a long-term care facility. Quantitative bronchial samples were obtained in 95 patients and 67 pathogens were identified. Organisms were gram-negative enteric bacilli (49%), anaerobic bacilli (16%), and S. aureus (12%); Prevotella and Fusobacterium species were the most common anaerobes. Aerobic gram-negative bacilli were recovered in conjunction with 55% of anaerobic isolates. Dental plaque did not differ between the aerobic and anaerobic groups. Functional status was the only determinant of anaerobic bacteria. Seven patients with anaerobic isolates initially received inadequate antimicrobial therapy, yet 6 had an effective clinical response. Crude mortality was 33% for the aerobic group and 36% for the anaerobic group. Multivariate analysis revealed hypoalbuminemia and the burden of comorbid diseases as independent risk factors for poor outcome. The authors conclude that anaerobes represent a significant proportion of oral flora in institutionalized elderly patients, but their role in causing aspiration pneumonia has been overemphasized.
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome In a clinical commentary, Tsang and Lam (84) discuss the experience of managing patients with SARS at Hong Kong University. In a pulmonary perspective, Shortridge (85) discusses the role of zoonotic incursions from southern China in the development of SARS and influenza. In an occasional essay, Zhong and Zeng (86) discusses strategies for fighting SARS.
Nosocomial Infections Destruction of the extracellular matrix is common in patients with hospital-acquired pneumonia. Hartog and coworkers (89) did mini-bronchoalveolar lavages in 30 patients with hospital-acquired pneumonia and 16 control subjects, and assessed activity of matrix metalloproteinases. Compared with the control subjects, the patients had 10-fold increases in metalloproteinase-8 and -9, whereas tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-1 was not increased. The active form of metalloproteinase-9 was found in 80% of the patients with pneumonia, but in none of the control subjects; neutrophils were the main source of the enzyme. Basal release of metalloproteinase was higher from pulmonary neutrophils than from blood neutrophils; pulmonary neutrophils were maximally activated. Concentrations of metalloproteinase were five times higher in patients with positive cultures than in patients with negative cultures. The levels of metalloproteinase were related to clinical severity. The authors conclude the neutrophil-derived metalloproteinases are increased in hospital-acquired pneumonia and are associated with positive cultures and clinical severity.
Massive Pulmonary Hemorrhage
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Monitoring Milic-Emili (94) recalls early studies on measurement of esophageal pressure.
Hemodynamic. Use of femoral-vein catheters is associated with a high risk of thrombosis despite prophylactic therapy. To assess the cost-effectiveness of routine lower extremity Doppler ultrasound screening in patients with femoral vein catheters, Cox and coworkers (96) developed a decision model. The analysis was based on a hypothetical cohort of 60-year-old medical patients being treated for acute respiratory failure. The costs of the ultrasound strategy were $8,688 per quality-adjusted life-year gained, $5,305 per pulmonary embolism averted, and $99,286 per death from pulmonary embolism averted. By varying in-hospital mortality, prevalence of deep-vein thrombosis, and ultrasound accuracy, the best-case cost was $1,170 and the worst-case costs was $35,342 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. Allowing for variation in variables of uncertain value, the median cost was $12,793 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. The authors conclude that routine ultrasound screening of patients with femoral vein catheters may improve outcomes at acceptable costs.
Nitric Oxide Inhalation of nitric oxide has been advocated as a method to prevent ischemiareperfusion injury after lung transplantation. Meade and coworkers (98) did a randomized controlled trial of inhaled nitric oxide (22 ppm) versus placebo in 83 patients, initiated 10 minutes after reperfusion. PO2/FIO2 was equivalent in the nitric oxide and placebo groups, 361 versus 351, on admission to the ICU. Severe hypoxemia, PO2/FIO2 less than 150, taken as an index of severe reperfusion injury, was present in 14.6% of the nitric oxide group and 9.5% of the control group. The nitric oxide and placebo groups had equivalent times to first trial of spontaneous breathing (medians of 25 versus 27 hours), successful extubation (32 versus 34 hours), ICU discharge (3 days for both), and hospital discharge (27 versus 29 days). Five patients in the nitric oxide and six in the placebo group died in the hospital. The authors conclude that inhaled nitric oxide shortly after reperfusion does not alter clinical outcome in patients undergoing lung transplantation. An editorial commentary by Glanville (99) accompanies this article. To measure fractions of exhaled nitric oxide in intubated, mechanically ventilated patients, Tornberg and coworkers (100) developed a method for obtaining multiple single-breath measurements at preset expiratory flows. A suction ejection system connected to a restriction valve was used to obtain multiple single-breath exhalations. Intubation produced a 50% decrease in the fraction of exhaled nitric oxide and a 36% decrease in the airway wall transfer rate of nitric oxide. Neither the fraction of nitric oxide originating in alveoli or in airway wall epithelium was affected by intubation. The peak concentration of nitric oxide after 20 seconds of apnea was similar to the value of nitric oxide calculated as originating in the airway wall epithelium. The authors conclude that the vacuum aspiration method for multiple single-breath measurements in mechanically ventilated patients enables the calculation of alveolar and bronchial fractions of nitric oxide. In dogs with cardiac failure induced by procainamide, Natori and coworkers (101) studied the cardiovascular effects of inhaled nitric oxide. Inhaled nitric oxide did not alter baseline left-ventricular function in control dogs or in dogs with heart failure. Inhaled nitric oxide decreased pulmonary vascular resistance in dogs with heart failure. Inhaled nitric oxide caused unexpected increases in left-ventricular end-diastolic pressure in the presence of both vasodilating agents (acetylcholine and nitroglycerin) and vasoconstricting agents (norepinephrine and angiotensin-II). End-diastolic left-ventricular dimension and wall stress were increased by inhaled nitric oxide, whereas end-systolic variables were not affected. The authors conclude that inhaled nitric oxide reduces pulmonary vascular resistance in dogs with heart failure but it also increases left-ventricular preload and end-diastolic wall stress. To determine whether endogenous endothelium-dependent vasoactive substances cause release of nitric oxide that can be detected in exhaled air, Malmstrom and coworkers (102) administered intravenously various pharmacologic compounds in anesthetized pigs and humans. Administration of acetylcholine, bradykinin, substance P, endothelin-1, and nitroglycerine produced dose-dependent increases of exhaled nitric oxide in pigs. Each compound caused a highly individual and reproducible release pattern. Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibition enhanced the release of nitric oxide induced by bradykinin. Endothelin receptor antagonism reduced the response of exhaled nitric oxide to endothelin-1. Atropine abolished the response to acetylcholine. Inhibition of nitric oxide synthase abolished the basal levels of exhaled nitric oxide, and also decreased the exhaled nitric oxide response to all compounds except nitroglycerine. In six human subjects, acetylcholine evoked a dose-dependent increased in exhaled nitric oxide. The authors conclude that release of nitric oxide in response to endogenous vasoactive compounds can be measured online in exhaled air.
Ethical Issues In an editorial, Tobin (105) discusses the role of a journal in a scientific controversy.
Nonpulmonary Critical Care
Trauma. To better define the pathology of blast injury to the lung, Tsokos and coworkers (108) studied autopsy specimens from eight people who died from close-range detonation of chemical explosives (four homicides, three suicides, and one accident). Histologic, immunohistochemical, and scanning electron microscopy revealed diffuse alveolar overdistension, circumscribed interstitial hemorrhages showing a cuff-like pattern around pulmonary vessels, venous air embolism, bone marrow embolism, and pulmonary fat embolism. Pulmonary fat embolism in this setting was independent of ventilation and was sufficient to produce ARDS in survivors. The authors conclude that blast injury to the lung secondary to close-range chemical detonation produces a relatively uniform picture of alveolar over-distension, circumscribed hemorrhage, venous embolism, and pulmonary fat embolism.
Gastroenterological disorders.
Cardiac disorders.
Hematological disorders. More than 40% of patients who develop acute chest syndrome secondary to sickle cell disease have fat droplets in their alveolar macrophages, which are suggestive of pulmonary fat embolism. To determine the reliability of induced sputum for diagnosing fat embolism, Lechapt and coworkers (112) did two studies. In 20 patients with acute chest syndrome, the number of Oil Red Ostained macrophages in induced sputum was correlated with the number in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (Spearman's coefficient, 0.66). In a second group of 60 patients with episodes of acute chest syndrome, sputum induction was successful in 47 patients. A diagnosis of pulmonary fat embolism (based on 5% of macrophages staining with Oil Red O) was made in 29 of the 47 patients with acute chest syndrome (61.7%) and none of 9 patients who did not have acute chest syndrome. Compared with patients who had acute chest syndrome but did not have pulmonary fat embolism, the patients with fat embolism were more likely to have additional extrathoracic pain (76 versus 50%), neurologic symptoms (7 versus 0%), abnormal transaminases (28 versus 17%), and a lower differential platelet count (-49 versus 85). The authors conclude that staining of induced sputum is a useful test for diagnosing pulmonary fat embolism in patients who have acute chest syndrome secondary to sickle cell disease.
Infectious disorders.
Neurologic and neuromuscular disorders.
Supported by a Merit Review grant from the Veterans Affairs Research Service. |