Published ahead of print on June 26, 2003, doi:10.1164/rccm.200211-1302OC
© 2003 American Thoracic Society
Nasal Airway Ion Transport and Lung Function in Young People with Cystic FibrosisInstitute of Child Health, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom; and Division of Pediatric Pulmonology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Helen L. Wallace, M.D., Institute of Child Health, Alder Hey Children's Hospital, Eaton Road, Liverpool L12 2AP UK. E-mail: hwallace{at}liv.ac.uk
There is strong evidence that abnormal airway ion transport is the primary defect that initiates the pathophysiology of lung disease in cystic fibrosis (CF). To examine the relationship between airway ion transport abnormality and severity of lung disease, we measured nasal potential difference in 51 young people with CF using a validated modified technique. There was no correlation between any component of the ion transport measurement and clinical condition (respiratory function, chest radiograph score, or Shwachman clinical score). Thirty subjects, homozygous for the F508 mutation, were divided into those above and those below average respiratory function for their age. There was no significant difference in any of the ion transport parameters between those with above and below average pulmonary function. Of the 51 subjects, 10 had significant hyperpolarization after perfusion with a zero Cl- solution (> 5 mV). This Cl- secretory capacity did not correlate with above average lung function. These data do not support the assertion that the extent of lung disease in CF reflects the degree of ion transport abnormality. We suggest that although an ion transport abnormality initiates lung disease, other factors (e.g., environmental and genetic modifiers) are more influential in determining disease severity.
Key Words: nasal potential difference FEV1 Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutation of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene and is characterized by profound abnormality of Na+ and Cl- transport across epithelia (1). CFTR normally functions as a cAMP-regulated chloride channel and influences other ion channels, most notably by downregulating the epithelial sodium channel (24). In CF airways, epithelial sodium channelmediated sodium ion absorption is increased and cAMP-mediated Cl- secretion diminished or absent. Extensive animal model and tissue culture studies have established a clear link between these airway ion transport abnormalities and the pathophysiology of CF lung disease (5). Dehydration of airway surface liquid, together with abnormal mucus production and decreased mucociliary clearance, exposes the airway to bacterial infection (6, 7). The subsequent cycle of chronic infection and extensive inflammation is well described (8). Over 1,000 mutations of the CFTR gene have been identified and this accounts, to some degree, for the variation in phenotype severity that characterizes CF (9). For example, certain mutations with residual CFTR function are associated with preservation of pancreatic function and delayed onset of clinical symptoms (10). However, the relationship between genotype, ion transport, and pulmonary disease is less conclusive (11). Wide intragenotype variation in the severity of pulmonary disease may reflect environmental factors, the presence of polymorphisms, or non-CFTR genetic modifiers (12, 13).
A number of studies have examined the influence of airway ion transport, as determined by nasal potential difference (PD) measurement, on the severity of lung disease. One group measured baseline PD in 95 adults and determined that the 10 patients with the lowest PDs had significantly better respiratory function irrespective of genotype (14). Other groups have not been able to reproduce these findings but have suggested some correlation between severity of lung disease and cAMP-mediated Cl- secretion (15, 16). A more robust examination of the influence of Cl- secretion on respiratory function was performed in a study of twin and sibling pairs, homozygous for The relationship between the extent of airway ion transport abnormality and the severity of lung disease is important because novel therapies are being directed toward correction, either by pharmacologic or molecular means, of the CF ion transport defect. In addition, clinical trials have employed nasal PD as a surrogate outcome measure on the assumption that normalizing the CF ion transport profile would improve long-term lung function. We examined prospectively the correlation between airway ion transport abnormality, as determined by nasal PD, and respiratory condition in young people with CF.
Subjects A definitive diagnosis of CF confirmed by raised sweat electrolytes (Cl- level > 60 mmol L-1) and/or identification of two diseaseassociated CFTR mutations was required for inclusion. Exclusion criteria included nasal polyposis, topical steroids, and acute rhinitis. Clinical assessment and nasal PD studies were undertaken at a point of stability (no respiratory symptoms (cough or wheeze) other than those normally experienced and no extra antibiotics). The Liverpool Health Authority Research Ethics Committee approved the study.
Clinical Assessment
Nasal PD Measurement
The following nasal PD parameters were recorded: (1) Stable maximal baseline PD (stable max PD; reflecting epithelial Na channelmediated Na+absorption); (2) the reduction in (1) after perfusion with 10-4 M amiloride ( At maximal baseline PD and following solution change, readings were taken from a point of stability (20 seconds).
Data Analysis
Three analyses were predetermined: (1) scatter plots were constructed to assess correlation between clinical measures and nasal PD parameters. Any relationships were examined with multiple regression analysis to construct a model to account for confounding variables (age, sex, genotype); (2) in order to account for natural decline in FEV1, patients homozygous for Values obtained for the CF group were compared with a non-CF group. Normality of the data distribution was assessed using the ShapiroWilk test and by examining histograms; the Student's t test or the MannWhitney U test was employed accordingly.
Subjects Nasal PD was measured in 51 young people with CF (34 males and 17 females, mean age 13.7 years, range 5.917.7; Table 1) . Thirty were homozygous for F508 and 14 were compound heterozygous for F508 and another recognized severe mutation. One was homozygous for G551D, and two were compound heterozygous for mutations associated with severe disease. Three patients (20, 21, 39) had Class IV or V mutations associated with a mild disease phenotype. One patient (pancreatic sufficient) had only one recognized mutation (G551D). Twelve young people without CF were also studied (five males and seven females, mean age 13.7 years, range 9.117.7).
Clinical Condition In the 51 subjects with CF, good correlation was demonstrated between each clinical parameter; FEV1, CXR score and Shwachman score (Figure 1 ; Pearson correlation, p < 0.01), i.e., patients with better lung function had lower CXR scores and higher Shwachman scores. Overall, the cohort had a wide range of lung function values (FEV1, 27120% predicted, Table 1).
Comparison between First Nostril Values and the Average of Both Nostrils Nasal PD measurements were well tolerated by all subjects. In 15 cases in the CF group, only one nostril was recorded to reduce the time of the procedure in patients who were unsettled. In the 36 patients who had both nostrils recorded, we compared the average of two nostril values to the first nostril value. Mean (±SEM) values for stable max PD were -44.7 ± 2.36 for both nostrils and -49.4 ± 2.8 for the first nostril. Values for zeroCl- were -1.4 ± 0.89 and -1.1 ± 1.14. BlandAltman plots (26) showed wide limits of agreement for stable max PD (-27.217.7) demonstrating the inherent variability of basal PD, and good limits of agreement for zeroCl- (-7.16.4; Figure 2)
. There was no evidence of bias toward either method.
Correlation between Nasal PD Results and Clinical Parameters in CF Patients There was no correlation between stable max PD and any of the clinical parameters as shown in Figure 3 (FEV1, r = 0.18, p = 0.2; CXR score, r = -2.7, p = 0.06; Shwachman score, r = 0.2, p = 0.16; Pearson correlation). Similarly, amil did not correlate with FEV1 (r = -1.4, p = 0.32), CXR score (r = 0.2, p = 0.17), or Shwachman score (r = -2.2, p = 0.13). There was no correlation between zeroCl-/iso and any of the clinical parameters (CXR, r = 0.03, p = 0.85; FEV1, r = -0.12, p = 0.4; Shwachman score r = 0.02, p = 0.87; Spearman's ). There was no correlation between ATP and clinical condition (CXR, r = 0.07, p = 0.65; Shwachman score r = -0.06, p = 0.68; Pearson correlation).
Relationship between FEV1 and Nasal PD in F508 PatientsThirty patients, homozygous for F508, were divided into two groups according to their FEV1 (above average, n = 16, Table 2) . There were no differences between the two groups for stable max PD (p = 0.73), amil (p = 0.56) or zeroCl-/iso (p = 0.78 MannWhitney U test) (Figure 4)
.
Effect of Genotype on Nasal PD Three patients had CFTR mutations associated with a mild phenotype (two were pancreatic sufficient). All three patients had stable max PD magnitude below 40 mV but no evidence of hyperpolarization after perfusion with zero Cl- solution.
"Chloride Secretors"
Comparison of PD Results in CF and Non-CF Subjects Nasal PD results for young people with and without CF are shown in Table 3 . Stable max PD and amil were significantly higher in the subjects with CF (stable max PD, p < 0.0001 t test; amil, p < 0.0001, t test,). Young people without CF had a greater hyperpolarization of PD after perfusion with zero Cl- solution ( zeroCl-/iso, p < 0.0001, MannWhitney U test). However, subjects with CF had a greater hyperpolarization after perfusion with ATP ( ATP, p < 0.03, t test).
The extent to which airway ion transport abnormalities influence the degree of lung disease in CF is an important issue because measurement of airway ion transport is widely used as a surrogate endpoint for clinical trials. Ion transport across nasal epithelia shares characteristics with more distal airways (27). Measurement of nasal PD has been used as a surrogate for more distal ion transport processes, and recent studies demonstrating distinct nasal PD profiles in adults susceptible to high altitude pulmonary edema suggest that this is valid (28). The ion transport abnormalities in CF initiate an environment that exposes the lung to repeated infection and inflammation. What remains unclear is whether the severity of lung disease is a result of the extent of ion transport abnormality and, if so, which component of ion transport is most influential. For example, is sodium ion hyperabsorption more important than lack of cAMP-mediated Cl- secretion, or are both critical to the initiation and/or development of CF lung disease.
This study examined the individual contribution of these ion transport processes to CF lung disease by prospectively examining the nasal PD profile of young people with CF. We did not demonstrate any significant relationship between ion transport and lung function. There was no relationship between the extent of sodium ion hyperabsorption (as determined by the stable maximal baseline PD and response to perfusion with amiloride) and FEV1. Chloride secretory capacity (as determined by the PD response to perfusion of a zero Cl- solution with isoprenaline) did not correlate with FEV1. An overall evaluation of subjects including all genotypes, showed no correlation between ion transport and clinical condition. In addition, patients with evidence of relatively high Cl- secretion ( The strengths of this study include the number of patients recruited and the wide range of clinical conditions in this cohort. In addition, the clinical parameters were assessed rigorously in an unbiased manner at a time of clinical stability. The finding of close correlation between these clinical parameters suggests that they are a true reflection of the clinical condition of the patients. A wide range of respiratory phenotype was demonstrated in this cohort increasing the power of the study to detect a significant correlation. Limitations of this study include the cross-sectional nature, the fact that only one nostril was measured in some patients and the natural decline in FEV1 that occurs in this age group. Patients who we have measured on more than one occasion show good repeatability (see Figure 6). Some of the younger patients had only one nostril recorded to reduce the measurement time. Although this would increase the variability of the test procedure, a separate analysis comparing first nostril values to the average of both nostrils showed no difference in the outcome of the study using either method. The decline in lung function with age was taken into account in the analysis by using average FEV1 values for age.
Previous studies have examined the relationship of nasal PD and lung disease (14, 15). Significant relationships have been reported; however, the clinical differences between groups are small. Thomas and coworkers report a correlation between FEV1 and
The finding of a chloride secretory capacity in patients with "severe" genotypes is consistent with previous nasal PD studies. Ho and coworkers identified a small number of "chloride secretors", at least one of whom was homozygous for
Data from the European study of This study was designed to examine the hypothesis, "Young people with severe CF lung disease have a more pronounced airway ion transport abnormality." Our data do not support this hypothesis. However, this study was underpowered to examine the ion transport characteristics of patients with mutations associated with a mild respiratory phenotype. Three such patients were included (although one had severe respiratory involvement). All had relatively low stable max PDs but no evidence of Cl- secretory capacity. A recent study found abnormal but varied nasal PD values in a small number of children with mutations associated with mild respiratory phenotype and intermediate sweat chloride levels (29). More work is needed in this area. Other factors may influence the degree of respiratory involvement in patients with CF. A number of studies have demonstrated association between certain genetic variants and respiratory function in CF. In particular, polymorphisms affecting the function of genes that mediate innate immunity and other inflammatory processes have been highlighted (3033). It is feasible that although the CF ion transport defect is the initiating step in CF lung pathology other factors may subsequently have more influence on the severity of lung involvement. To summarize, we examined a large cohort of young people with CF with a wide spectrum of lung disease. We did not detect any relationship between the extent of lung disease and the extent of airway ion transport abnormality as determined by nasal PD measurement. These findings are consistent with the views of other groups who suggest a "point of no return" when referring to the development of lung disease in CF (34). Although airway ion transport plays a key role in establishing an environment for lung disease in CF, it seems likely that other factors have more influence on the extent of that involvement.
The authors would like to thank the young people who helped with this study, Dan Gillie for technical advice, Dr. Gill Lancaster for statistical advice, and Dr. Ken Friedman for information regarding genotype analysis.
Supported by grants and fellowships (H.L.W.) from the United Kingdom Cystic Fibrosis Trust and the Medical Research Council. Received in original form November 8, 2002; accepted in final form June 25, 2003
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||