Published ahead of print on December 12, 2002, doi:10.1164/rccm.200206-616OC
© 2003 American Thoracic Society
Effects of Early Onset Asthma and In Utero Exposure to Maternal Smoking on Childhood Lung FunctionDepartment of Preventive Medicine, Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Frank Gilliland, M.D., Department of Preventive Medicine, USC Keck School of Medicine, 1540 Alcazar Street, CHP 236, Los Angeles, CA 90033. E-mail: gillilan{at}usc.edu
Both in utero exposures to maternal smoking and asthma are associated with chronic deficits in lung function. We hypothesized that in utero exposure affects lung function in children without asthma and synergistically affects children with early onset asthma. To investigate effects of in utero exposure and age at asthma diagnosis on lung function, we examined longitudinal medical history, tobacco smoke exposure, and lung function data from 5,933 participants in the Children's Health Study. We found that children exposed in utero, but without asthma, showed decreased FEV1/FVC, FEF2575, and FEF2575/FVC ratio. Among children without in utero exposure, early asthma diagnosis was associated with larger decreases in FEV1, FEF2575, and FEV1/FVC ratio compared with later diagnosed asthma. Children with in utero exposure alone and early onset asthma showed deficits in FEV1 (-13.6%; 95% confidence interval [CI], -18.9 to -8.2) and FEF2575 (-29.7%; 95% CI, -37.8 to -20.5) among boys; and FEF2575 (-26.6%; 95% CI, -36.4 to -15.1) and FEV1/FVC (-9.3%; 95% CI, -12.9 to -5.4) among girls. The absolute differences in FEF2575 associated with in utero exposure increased with age in children with early onset asthma. We found little evidence for effects from environmental tobacco smoke exposure alone. In summary, deficits in lung function were largest among children with in utero exposure and early onset asthma.
Key Words: asthma children ETS maternal smoking Low adult lung function has been associated with elevated morbidity and mortality (1). The evidence that variation of lung function in the general population influences mortality suggests that the achievement of maximum attainable lung function may be an important determinant of population health. Achievement of maximum attainable lung function at maturity requires normal lung growth and development during childhood (24). A better understanding of the determinants of lung growth and development may provide useful insights for lung health promotion and disease prevention efforts. A number of determinants of childhood lung function growth have been identified (59). Both in utero exposures to maternal smoking and asthma, especially early onset asthma, have been linked to chronic reductions in lung function during childhood and adolescence (6, 10). Because asthma and lung function are complex, interrelated traits that are both associated with in utero exposure, the interrelationships between in utero exposure, asthma occurrence, and lung function are yet to be established. On the basis of the existing evidence, we hypothesized that (1) in utero exposure is directly associated with lung function in children without asthma; (2) asthma is independently associated with lung function in children without in utero exposure; and (3) in utero exposure synergistically affects lung function in children with asthma, especially among children with early onset asthma. The Children's Health Study, a cohort study of schoolchildren's respiratory health, offered an opportunity to assess the effects of in utero exposure to maternal smoking and age at asthma diagnosis. To investigate the independent and joint effects of in utero exposure to maternal smoking and age at asthma diagnosis on lung function, we examined longitudinal medical history, tobacco smoke exposure, and lung function data collected over the first 8 years of the study from a cohort of 5,933 participants in the Children's Health Study. Some of the results of these studies have been previously reported in the form of an abstract (11).
Children were recruited from public school classrooms in 12 southern California communities that were selected on the basis of historical measurements of air quality, demographic similarities, and a cooperative school district. The design, site selection, subject recruitment, and assessment of health effects have been previously reported (12, 13). Briefly, at study entry in 1993, a parent or guardian of each participating child provided written informed consent and completed a self-administered questionnaire on demographics, medical and family health history, indoor air exposures, and household characteristics. In the spring of 1993 and in each subsequent year of the ongoing study, each child completed an update questionnaire, and pulmonary function testing was conducted at schools. In 1996, a second group of 4th grade students was recruited and completed the same baseline and follow-up questionnaires and pulmonary function testing as the group enrolled in 1993. In this report, we examine longitudinal data collected during the first 8 years of the study.
Sociodemographic, Medical History, and Exposure Data
Statistical Analysis
The primary parameter of interest is the coefficient We assessed potential confounders of the relationship between tobacco smoke exposure, asthma, and lung function. Subjects with missing data for a given covariate were excluded from the analyses involving that covariate. On the basis of previous analyses, parental education (less than 12 grades, 12 grades, some college, college, and some graduate), household income (less than $7,500; $7,500 to $14,999; $15,000 to $29,999; $30,000 to $49,999; $50,000 to $99,999; and more than $100,000), insurance status (yes/no), body mass index (BMI [kg/m2], age- and sex-specific quintiles), low birth weight (less than 5 lb, 5 lb or more), early chest illness excluding asthma (any before 2 years of age versus none), hay fever (any versus none), house water damage (yes/no), live plants in the house (yes/no), vigorous exercise within half an hour of the lung function test (yes/no), and respiratory illness at lung function test (yes/no) were evaluated as potential confounders. Variables were included in models if the adjusted estimates changed by 10% or more compared with the unadjusted estimates. All analyses were done with the linear mixed-effects model function (LME) of the SPlus statistical software package (Mathsoft, Seattle, WA).
Participant characteristics at study entry are presented in Table 1 . The 5,933 children ranged in age from 7 to 18 years at the beginning of follow-up. At study entry, 8.7% of participants had been diagnosed with asthma at age 5 years or younger and 8.6% were diagnosed after age 5 years. Almost 19% were exposed in utero to maternal smoking and 32% had any lifetime ETS exposure.
We found substantial deficits in lung function among children with in utero exposure to maternal smoking and early onset asthma (Tables 2 and 3) . Boys and girls exposed in utero to maternal smoking, but without a history of asthma, showed deficits in FEF2575, and a decrease in the FEV1/FVC and FEF2575/FVC ratios. Conversely, both boys and girls with early onset asthma who were unexposed in utero showed deficits in FEV1 (liters per second) and FEF2575 (liters per second), and a decrease in the FEV1/FVC and FEF2575/FVC ratios. Children with in utero exposure and early onset asthma had large percent deficits for FEV1 (-8.8%; 95% confidence interval [CI], -11.5 to -5.9%), FEF2575 (-23.6%; 95% CI, -28.3 to -18.7%), and FEF2575/FVC (-22.4%; 95% CI, -27.1 to -17.4%) among boys; and in FEV1/FVC (-5.4%; 95% CI, -7.1 to -3.7%), FEF2575 (-14.9%; 95% CI, -20.1 to 9.4%), and FEF2575/FVC (-19.0%; 95% CI, -23.9 to -13.7%) among girls. The effects of in utero exposure to maternal smoking were significantly larger (p < 0.05) for both boys (FEV1, FEF2575, and the FEV1/FVC and FEF2575/FVC ratios) and girls (FEF2575 and the FEV1/FVC and FEF2575/FVC ratios) with early onset asthma (5 years old or less at diagnosis) than asthma onset at an older age. The deficits in lung function associated with early and later onset asthma, and in utero exposure to maternal smoking, were essentially unchanged after adjustment for lifetime ETS exposure and personal smoking.
To further investigate the effects of in utero exposure to maternal smoking with and without ETS exposure, we assessed lung function levels using mutually exclusive exposure categories (Tables 4 and 5) . Compared with nonasthmatic children unexposed to ETS and maternal smoking in utero, children with in utero exposure alone and early onset asthma showed deficits in FEV1 (-13.6%; 95% CI, -18.9 to 8.2%), FEV1/FVC (-9.1%; 95% CI, -12.2 to -5.8%), FEF2575 (-29.7%; 95% CI, -37.8 to -20.5%), and FEF2575/FVC (-25.9%; 95% CI, -34.5 to -16.2%) among boys; and in FEV1/FVC (-9.3%; 95% CI, -12.9 to -5.4%), FEF2575 (-26.6%; 95% CI, -36.4 to -15.1%), and FEF2575/FVC (-29.9%; 95% CI, -39.5 to -18.9%) among girls. We found that ETS exposure alone was not significantly associated with persistent deficits in lung function in any subgroup after considering the effects of early and later onset asthma. Among children without asthma, joint exposure to ETS and maternal smoking in utero was associated with significant deficits in flows; however, the joint effect of ETS and in utero exposure was of similar magnitude as for in utero exposure alone and was not significantly different from the effect of in utero exposure alone. Among children with asthma, the deficits in FEV1 in boys and FEF2575/FVC and FEF2575 were smaller in girls with early onset asthma and who were exposed to both in utero and ETS exposures than girls exposed to in utero maternal smoking alone. The associations between lung function, early and later onset asthma, and in utero exposure to maternal smoking were essentially unchanged after adjustment for personal smoking.
We found that the deficits in lung function associated with in utero exposure and early onset asthma persisted into adolescence (Tables 6 and 7) . Among girls, the percent deficits in lung function associated with in utero exposure and asthma status did not change with age except among unexposed girls with early onset asthma, who showed increasing deficits in FEF2575 with age. The magnitude of the percent deficits in FEF2575 and the FEV1/FVC ratio associated with in utero exposure in boys without asthma did not change with age. The percent deficits among unexposed boys with early onset asthma increased by 0.2%/year of age for FEV1. Late onset asthma in unexposed boys showed a larger percent deficit with age for FEV1 (-0.6%/year), FVC (-0.2%/year), FEV1/FVC ratio (-0.3%/year), FEF2575 (-0.8%/year), and FEF2575/FVC ratio (-0.6%/year).
The percent deficits in FEV1, FVC, FEF2575, and the FEV1/FVC and FEF2575/FVC ratios decreased significantly with increasing age among the boys with early onset asthma who were exposed in utero. For example, the 27.7% deficit in FEF2575 among boys decreased by 1.9% between ages 10 and 11 years. This age trend was not observed among girls. To illustrate the effects of the changes in deficits with age on predicted lung function level, we calculated the predicted lung function level at ages 10 and 15 years, using the covariates for non-Hispanic white children with average height at their age and with different asthma status and in utero exposure combinations (Tables 8 and 9) . We found that the effects of in utero exposure to maternal smoking on FEV1 and FEF2575 increased with age among children without asthma and among those with early onset asthma. Although the percent deficits in lung function decreased significantly as age increased among the boys with early onset asthma who were exposed in utero, the absolute deficit increased with age. Children exposed in utero who had late onset asthma presented a different pattern than did children with early onset asthma, and the absolute deficits were smaller at age 10 years and decreased by age 15 years.
We found that early onset asthma and in utero exposure to maternal smoking were associated with large persistent deficits in measures of airflow and that the deficits were largest among exposed children who developed early onset asthma. Previous studies of the relationship between in utero exposure and lung function in children have not reported the independent and joint associations of early onset asthma and in utero exposure among boys and girls (7, 19, 20). Our findings support the hypothesis that in utero exposure and early onset asthma are synergistically associated with persistent deficits in lung function and indicate that children with early onset asthma may be a high-risk group for subsequent adverse respiratory health outcomes during their life course. We did not observe an independent effect of ETS exposure on lung function. A growing body of evidence supports the plausibility that in utero exposure to maternal smoking can produce persistent deficits in childhood lung function and that the deficits may be larger in children with asthma (7, 19, 2128). Studies of lung function in newborns and infants of mothers who smoked during pregnancy show that in utero exposure is associated with reduced lung function in the perinatal period (22, 23, 26, 27, 29). Studies among newborns in eastern Boston, Massachusetts, and Perth, Australia, which excluded effects of ETS by measuring lung function near birth, reported an independent effect of in utero exposure on respiratory mechanics (22, 29). The perinatal deficits from in utero exposure may be larger in children who subsequently develop asthma. Stick and coworkers reported that newborns with a family history of asthma had larger deficits in lung function from in utero exposure compared with newborns without a family history of asthma (29). Our findings suggest that the perinatal deficits in lung function from in utero exposure to maternal smoking are persistent and increasingly large during adolescence, especially among children who were diagnosed with asthma at an early age. Martinez and coworkers showed that prewheezing lung function persisted into later childhood, even in those children who stopped wheezing. These data support the hypothesis that there is a persistent underlying airflow abnormality independent of wheezing status (30). The large and increasing deficits may be important because in utero exposure to maternal smoking has been associated with higher incidence of asthma, more severe disease, an earlier onset of the disease, and an increased likelihood of using asthma medications (10, 31). The biological mechanisms that account for the deficits associated with in utero exposure among children with early onset asthma have yet to be established. Airway structures are present at birth but continue developing and growing in the postnatal period. Because the effects of in utero exposure appear to be independent from the effects of postnatal ETS exposure, the deficits from in utero exposure may reflect damage during critical periods of fetal development that permanently alters the structure or function of the lung, such as its elastic recoil properties, smooth muscle, epithelial organization, neural function, or immune function (7). Studies of rodents exposed to tobacco smoke during the in utero period show that newborns have increased bronchial reactivity (32). Increased bronchial reactivity may lead to increased risk of wheezing illnesses during infancy, asthma, and deficits in lung function growth during childhood. Any direct effects of in utero exposure on lung development may be amplified by asthma, which is associated with both in utero exposure and chronic deficits in lung function. The effects may also be mediated through the increased occurrence of perinatal respiratory problems or infections associated with in utero exposure (33). Mechanistic studies are needed to better understand these physiologic and anatomic changes that account for our findings. Our study had some limitations that need to be considered when interpreting the results. Asthma is a complex clinical syndrome. In this study, asthma status was assigned on the basis of parental reports of age at physician diagnosis of asthma. Parent reports have been widely used in epidemiologic studies and shown to reflect physician diagnoses; however, the diagnosis of asthma by a physician may depend on access and utilization of medical care as well as physician diagnostic practices (34, 35). We considered factors associated with access and utilization of medical care such as insurance, education, and income and found no substantial change in the associations between in utero exposure, asthma, and lung function. This suggests that differences in access and utilization of medical care are unlikely to account for our results. To further investigate the effects of undiagnosed asthma in our study population, we examined the effects of wheezing in the 12 months before study entry in children without asthma (56 boys and 57 girls). We found that children with wheezing but without diagnosed asthma showed no reductions in lung function compared with children without asthma or wheeze. In utero exposure was associated with lung function deficits in undiagnosed children with and without wheezing. The magnitude of the deficits from in utero exposure were smaller in undiagnosed children with wheezing than in children with early onset asthma. Because the number of undiagnosed children with wheezing was small in our population and the effects of in utero exposure were smaller than in children with early onset asthma, bias from undiagnosed asthma cannot explain our results as the presence of undiagnosed asthma in the reference group would produce a small bias toward no effect. Errors in measurement of in utero and chronic levels of postnatal ETS exposure are another potential source of bias. Exposure to tobacco smoke was assessed retrospectively, using questionnaire responses, and was not validated by objective measurements such as cotinine or nicotine levels. However, exposure estimates based on questionnaire responses have been validated by other investigators (3640). The pattern of stronger effects from in utero than ETS exposure may have arisen from differential measurement error for ETS compared with in utero exposure. The measurement error for ETS is likely to be larger than for in utero exposure and may produce a larger bias toward the null for ETS estimates. In utero exposure was reported at study entry and errors in reporting are unlikely to bias the associations with lung function measured prospectively. We were unable to investigate any doseresponse relationships for in utero exposure in the entire cohort because we lacked information about the intensity or duration of exposure. In an ongoing case-control study nested in the cohort, we have observed that 15% of women who smoked at conception quit smoking during the first trimester and 84% continued to smoke during the pregnancy. In this study, women smoked an average of half a pack per day while pregnant. These data indicate that most women in the study were light smokers, but the majority continued to smoke throughout pregnancy. We also lacked information about a number of potential confounders such as maternal nutritional status and intake of alcohol or other potentially toxic substances during pregnancy. Our findings may have clinical and public health significance. The long-term effects of in utero exposure on the growing lungs of children with early onset asthma are of particular concern. If the growing deficits continue and persist into adulthood, children with early onset asthma may be at increased risk for debilitating symptoms from asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (24, 33, 41). Reducing the long-term effects of tobacco smoke on children with asthma may require the reduction of smoking among women during their childbearing years. Furthermore, clinicians need to be aware of this high-risk group in treatment decision-making. In conclusion, school-aged children with early onset asthma and in utero exposure to maternal smoking show large deficits in lung function, especially airflows that are not explained by postnatal ETS exposure. Because early onset asthma itself is associated with substantial chronic deficits in lung function, the additional deficits associated with in utero exposure may produce a group at high risk for adult chronic respiratory diseases. Further research is needed to clarify the roles of in utero exposure to maternal smoking and of asthma phenotypes on lung growth and development.
The authors thank Ms. Dorothy Starnes for providing technical support in the preparation of this manuscript.
Supported by the California Air Resources Board (contract A033186), the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (grants 1 P01 ES0958104 and 5 P30 ES0704808), the US Environmental Protection Agency (grant R82670801), the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (grant 1 R01 HL6176803), and the Hastings Foundation. Disclaimer: The statements and conclusions in this report are those of the investigators and not necessarily those of the California Air Resources Board, the Environmental Protection Agency, or the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. The mention of commercial products, their source, or their use in connection with material reported herein is not to be construed as either an actual or implied endorsement of such products. Received in original form June 26, 2002; accepted in final form December 6, 2002
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||