Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.,
Volume 158, Number 5, November 1998, S176-S178
Dynamically Determined Contractile States of
Airway Smooth Muscle
SOUFIA HELIOUI
RABOUDI,
BRETT
MILLER,
JAMES P.
BUTLER,
STEPHANIE A.
SHORE,
and
JEFFREY J.
FREDBERG
Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts
 |
ABSTRACT |
The contractile state of maximally activated bovine airway smooth muscle is altered during imposed
tidal stretches that simulate the action of breathing. When the amplitude of imposed tidal stretch is
very small (0.25% of muscle optimal length), the steady-state value of the muscle force, F, approximates the isometric force, the muscle stiffness, E, is large, and the muscle hysteresivity,
, is small.
When the amplitude is increased beyond 1%, however, F and E promptly decrease and
promptly
increases. The provocative stretch amplitude required to cause active force or muscle stiffness to fall
by half, or hysteresivity to double, is slightly greater than 2%. By contrast, the stretch amplitude expected during quiet breathing at rest is 4%. Therefore, the isometric force generating capacity of airway smooth muscle may not be applicable to the force generated in normal physiologic circumstances, even during maximal bronchial provocation. Raboudi SH, Miller B, Butler JP, Shore SA,
Fredberg JJ. Dynamically determined contractile states of airway smooth muscle.
 |
INTRODUCTION |
With the onset of a maximal contractile stimulus of isometric
airway smooth muscle, myosin-actin cycling begins and the
number of interactions (bridges) increases and approaches a
plateau. During this process, rapidly cycling crossbridges convert progressively to slowly cycling latch bridges. This regulatory process eventually progresses to a steady state, and
bridge dynamics are then said to have attained the latch state
(1). In the latch state, the rate of bridge cycling has decreased to its smallest value attainable in maximally activated
muscle (excepting the rigor state), the active force has increased to its maximum attainable value, and that value of the
force defines one point on the static force-length characteristic of the muscle.
Like the unloaded shortening velocity after a quick release
(Figure 1) and the rate of actomyosin ATP utilization, the hysteresivity of airway smooth muscle is also governed by the rate
of bridge turnover. Because it can be measured continuously
throughout the contractile event, whereas shortening velocity
cannot, the hysteresivity provides a convenient window on the
rate of bridge turnover and its changes in time. Using the muscle hysteresivity as a probe of bridge cycling rate, and muscle
force and stiffness as probes of bridge numbers, we have extended the earlier work of Gunst and colleagues (4) and
Sasaki and Hoppin (7). We studied isolated, maximally contracted tracheal smooth muscle and assessed the way in which
the interactions of myosin with actin are altered as a result of
imposed stretches that simulate the effects of tidal breathing.

View larger version (21K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 1.
Velocity of shortening (in optimal lengths per second)
on the left ordinate (open squares) and hysteresivity on the right
ordinate (closed circles) measured as a function of time (t) after the
onset of electrical field stimulation in canine trachealis. Maximal
velocity (Vmax) was measured over the interval from 250 ms to
400 ms after the quick release to a small afterload, typically 1-2%
of the maximum isometric force. Inset: regression line, Vmax = 1.91 + 0.0, r2 = 0.98, p = 0.0001, Fisher's z transform. (Reprinted with permission from Reference 3.)
|
|
 |
EFFECTS OF TIDAL STRETCH |
We consider bovine tracheal smooth muscle mounted in a
muscle bath (Krebs-Heinseleit solution, 37° C, aerated with
95% O2-5% CO2) and set to optimal length (Lo), where active force is maximal (Fo), and impose about Lo a sinusoidal
length fluctuation of amplitude
L (2
L peak-to-peak) and
frequency of 0.33 Hz, as might occur during tidal breathing.
The amplitude of the imposed tidal stretch,
(
L/Lo expressed
as a percent), is maintained at a very small level, 0.25%, until
the muscle is fully activated and the force versus length loop
attains a steady-state configuration. Tidal stretch is then increased to either 0.5, 1, 2, 4, or 8%. From the resulting force
versus length loops, we computed the mean force over the
stretch cycle, F, the muscle stiffness, E, and the muscle hysteresivity,
.
When
is maintained at 0.25%, addition of acetylcholine
(ACh) to the bath (10
4 M ACh at t = 100 s) causes E and F
to increase monotonically and at similar rates (solid lines, Figure 2, top and center panels). Both attain plateau values within
300 s. Changes of
, by contrast, are prominently dissociated
from those of E and F (solid line, Figure 2, bottom panel). Addition of ACh causes
to follow a biphasic pattern in which it
increases rapidly, peaks early in the contraction, and thereafter decreases slowly. Muscle hysteresivity also attains a plateau value within about 300 s. As with baseline values of passive muscle force and stiffness, the baseline value of muscle
is attributable to the passive mechanical properties of connective tissues. As such, these changes in
probably reflect rapidly
cycling crossbridges early in the contractile event converting to
slowly cycling latch bridges later in the contractile event.

View larger version (32K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 2.
Time courses of total force averaged succeeding stretch
periods (top panel ), stiffness (center panel ), and hysteresivity (bottom panel ) in a representative tracheal smooth muscle strip. Solid
line in each panel corresponds to maintained throughout at
0.25%. Broken lines correspond to runs in the same muscle subjected to graded increments of from 0.25 to either 0.5, 1, 2, 4, or 8% over the time interval from 400 to 900 s. Control values are
those measured at t = 400 s with = 0.25%. (Reprinted with permission from Reference 10.)
|
|
Increasing tidal stretch amplitude causes F and E to decrease promptly and
to increase promptly, within two to
three stretches (broken lines, Figure 2, where
was increased
from 0.25% to a larger value at 400 s). The greater the increase in
, the greater are the resulting changes in F, E, and
.
Thereafter, the airway smooth muscle can be maintained in
steady, dynamically determined contractile states that differ
demonstrably from the state in isometric conditions. The plateau values of F, E, and
at t = 900 s are plotted versus
in Figure 3. F and E are expressed as a percent of their respective values measured at t = 400 s with
= 0.25%, which approximate isometric steady-state conditions. As
is increased
from this level, F and E progressively decrease and
progressively increases (Figure 3).

View larger version (22K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 3.
Plateau values (t = 900 s) of the stretch cycle (F) and the
muscle stiffness (E) during tidal stretch expressed as a percent of
control (values measured at t = 400 s with = 0.25%); values of
muscle hysteresivity ( ) are absolute. The provocative stretch amplitude required to cause F or E to fall by half, or to double, was
slightly greater than 2%. (Reprinted with permission from Reference 10.)
|
|
 |
THE DYNAMICALLY DETERMINED MUSCLE STATE |
These data show that maximally stimulated airway smooth
muscle can be maintained in steady, dynamically determined
contractile states for as long as the contractile stimulus and the
tidal stretches are sustained. These states are characterized by
graded stretch-effect relations in which the greater the tidal
stretch amplitude, the greater are the departures of muscle
force, muscle stiffness, and muscle hysteresivity from their values measured in conditions approximating the isometric steady
state. The provocative stretch amplitude required to cause active force or muscle stiffness to fall by half, or hysteresivity to
double, is slightly greater than 2%. Because muscle stiffness is
a rough reflection of the numbers of actin-myosin interactions, and muscle hysteresivity is a rough reflection of the rate
of turnover of those interactions (3), these results suggest that
tidal stretch decreases the numbers of actin-myosin interactions and increases their turnover rate, although the effects of
muscle plasticity may be important as well (8, 9). The dependencies of F, E, and
upon tidal stretch amplitude are uninfluenced by treatment of the tissues with tetrodotoxin and indomethacin, ruling out the importance of mechanisms based
upon stretch-activated neural pathways or prostanoid release.
 |
FUNCTIONAL IMPLICATIONS |
If muscle stretch scales isotropically as the cube root of lung
volume change (10), then normal tidal lung inflations from functional residual capacity (FRC) would correspond roughly
to
of 4%, a sigh from FRC would correspond roughly to
of
12%, and inflation from FRC to total lung capacity would correspond roughly to
to 25%. By contrast, the provocative
stretch amplitude required to cause active force or muscle stiffness to fall by half, or hysteresivity to double, is slightly greater
than 2% (Figure 3). Thus, small tidal stretches, even smaller
than would be expected with normal tidal breathing, are seen
to be a potent endogenous relaxing mechanism, and one that
expresses its greatest sensitivity to muscle stretch remarkably
close to the range that would be expected to occur during
spontaneous breathing. Accordingly, it is conceivable if not
likely that when airway smooth muscle of normal individuals
is maximally stimulated, it operates on the part of the stretch-
effect relationship (Figure 3) where force is profoundly inhibited (
4%). If so, then the isometric force-generating
capacity of airway smooth muscle may not be applicable to the
force generated in normal physiologic circumstances, even during maximal bronchial provocation.
 |
Footnotes |
Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Jeffrey Fredberg, Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, 665 Huntington Ave., Boston, MA 02115. E-mail: jfredber{at}hsph.harvard.edu
Acknowledgments:
Supported in part by PO1 HL-33009 and RO1 HL-59682.
 |
References |
1.
Murphy, R. A..
1994.
What is special about smooth muscle? The significance of covalent crossbridge regulation.
FASEB J.
8:
311-318
.
2.
Hai, C. M., and
R. A. Murphy.
1988.
Regulation of shortening velocity
by cross-bridge phosphorylation in smooth muscle.
Am. J. Physiol.
255:
C86-C94
.
3.
Fredberg, J. J.,
K. A. Jones,
M. Nathan,
S. Raboudi,
Y. S. Prakash,
S. A. Shore,
J. P. Butler, and
G. C. Sieck.
1996.
Friction in airway smooth
muscle mechanism: latch and implications in asthma.
J. Appl. Physiol.
81:
2703-2712
.
4.
Warner, D. O., and
S. J. Gunst.
1992.
Limitation of maximal bronchoconstriction in living dogs.
Am. Rev. Respir. Dis.
145:
553-560
.
5.
Gunst, S. J.,
J. Q. Stropp, and
J. Service.
1990.
Mechanical modulation of
pressure-volume characteristics of contracted canine airways in vitro.
J. Appl. Physiol.
68:
2223-2229
.
6.
Shen, X.,
M. F. Wu,
R. S. Tepper, and
S. J. Gunst.
1997.
Pharmacological
modulation of the mechanical response of airway smooth muscle to
length oscillation.
J. Appl. Physiol.
83:
730-745
.
7.
Sasaki, H., and F. G. Hoppin, Jr. 1979. Hysteresis of contracted airway
smooth muscle. J. Appl. Physiol.: Respirat. Environ. Exercise Physiol.
47:1251-1262.
8.
Pratusevich, V. R.,
C. Y. Seow, and
L. E. Ford.
1995.
Plasticity in canine
airway smooth muscle.
J. Gen. Physiol.
105:
73-94
.
9.
Gunst, S. J.,
R. A. Meiss,
M.-F. Wu, and
M. Rowe.
1995.
Mechanisms for
the mechanical placticity of tracheal smooth muscle.
Am. J. Physiol.
268:
C1267-C1276
.
10.
Fredberg, J. J.,
B. Miller,
S. Jafari,
M. Nathan,
S. Helioui,
Raboudi,
J. P. Butler, and
S. A. Shore.
1997.
Airway smooth muscle, tidal stretches
and dynamically determined contractile states.
Am. J. Respir. Crit.
Care Med.
156:
1752-1759
.