Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.,
Volume 159, Number 3, March 1999, 824-828
Comparison of Oral Bambuterol and Inhaled
Salmeterol in Patients with Symptomatic
Asthma and Using Inhaled Corticosteroids
GRAHAM K.
CROMPTON,
JON G.
AYRES,
GURNAM
BASRAN,
GIANFRANCO
SCHIRALDI,
VITO
BRUSASCO,
ARNE
EIVINDSON,
AUDREY H.
JAMIESON,
and
HÅKAN
OLSSON
Western General Hospital and Astra Clinical Research Unit, Edinburgh; Birmingham Heartlands Hospital, Birmingham; and
Rotherham District Hospital, Rotherham, United Kingdom; Ospedale Niguarda, Milan; and Facoltà di Medicina e Chirurgia,
Università di Genova, Italy; Aust-Agder Sentralsjukehus, Arendal, Norway; and Astra Draco AB, Lund, Sweden
Salmeterol inhaled twice-daily is now being used more frequently as additional treatment in asthma
insufficiently controlled by inhaled corticosteroids. We compared oral bambuterol in a dose of 20 mg
taken once daily in the evening with inhaled salmeterol at 50 µg taken twice daily in 126 asthmatic
patients (60 bambuterol, 66 salmeterol) aged 18 to 74 yr who were treated for at least 4 wk with inhaled corticosteroids at a constant dose of 400 to 2,000 µg/d or with oral corticosteroids at
20 mg/d. The patients were able to use a pressurized metered dose inhaler (pMDI) efficiently, and had
an FEV1 of 40 to 85% of the predicted normal value. During a run-in period, patients had to show at
least one nocturnal or early awakening caused by asthma symptoms that required rescue medication,
and a
15% overnight decrease in peak expiratory flow (PEF) on 3 of the preceding 7 d, in order to
be randomized into this double-blind, double dummy, multicenter parallel group study (2-wk run-in
period and 6 wk of treatment). There was no significant difference between bambuterol and salmeterol in morning change from baseline in PEF (p = 0.53). The median increases in morning PEF were
50 L/min for bambuterol and 55 L/min for salmeterol. Other variables (evening PEF, percent of overnight decrease in PEF, number of awakenings, percent of nights with an awakening, number of puffs
of rescue medication, asthma symptoms during the day and night, and mean tremor score) also
showed no significant difference between bambuterol and salmeterol. Both treatments, at the doses
given, were well tolerated. Once-daily oral bambuterol is a convenient, effective, and less expensive
alternative to twice-daily inhaled salmeterol for treating nocturnal asthma.